Browsing by Author "Ogbuoji, Osondu"
Results Per Page
Sort Options
Item Open Access A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Timely Otitis Media Treatment through a Community Health Worker Delivered School Screening Program(2023-04-19) Johri, MohiniIn certain settings, otitis-media related hearing loss forms a large proportion of total hearing loss cases. Delays to timely otitis media diagnosis and appropriate treatment leads to more serious otitis media cases, sometimes chronic suppurative otitis media, which may lead to a permanent hearing loss. A primary driver in the delay to diagnosis and treatment is a lack of easily accessed, trained healthcare workers in the identification and treatment of otitis media. We used an exemplar setting, Zambia, to understand the costs and potential effects of community health worker-delivered screening program for school-age children. The goal of this analysis was to highlight otitis media as a driver of hearing loss and understand the cost-effectiveness of timely diagnosis/treatment to prevent downstream hearing loss. The treatment pathway for otitis media treatment was identified using a cascade of care framework, as well as the effects of increased otitis media treatment access though stakeholder engagement metrics. The treatment for otitis media in this analysis was conservative treatment, aural toileting and topical antibiotics. Additionally, the costs of otitis media and chronic suppurative otitis media and the proportion of both metrics treated in Nigeria were found. Training costs of a program were included in the treatment pathway to adequately model the scale-up strategy. Simulated persons experience yearly age- and sex- specific probabilities of acquiring hearing loss, the prevalence of which is 3.6% in Nigeria. The population of interest was six-year-old children in Nigeria suffering from otitis media across their lifetime. Strategies for comparison to increase appropriate treatment of otitis media included current care and the implementation of a community health worker-delivered screening program. Main measures included lifetime undiscounted and discounted (3%/year) costs and QALYs and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) by Nigerian standard (<3x $2,097.09 was considered cost-effective). Current detection (CD) resulted in 19.22 discounted average person-years of otitis media treatment compared to 19.23 discounted average person-years with implementation of a CHW delivered screening program. Lifetime total per-person undiscounted costs were $64.26 USD for CD and $62.26 USD with the screening program intervention, indicating that the screen is both less costly and more effective than not screening. Results were most sensitive to variations in cost of screen, cost of CSOM, rAOM, pOME resolution from screening, and CI device cost. Limitations included input uncertainty given limited data sources for similar settings. Additionally, we had to use a utility decrement for moderate hearing loss since there is not one in the model that we identified specifically for CSOM. We project that a community health worker delivered screening program is cost-effective by US standards. Further research is needed to determine whether screening at younger ages or different treatments for otitis media is cost-effective.Item Open Access Building a Decision Model to Estimate the Health and Economic Benefits of Targeted Mental Health Interventions to Improve ART Adherence among Young People Living with HIV in Tanzania(2023) Fawole, Ayodamope OlaoluwaYoung people living with HIV (YPLWH) constitute a growing proportion of the global population of people living with HIV but have less access to HIV testing, diagnosis, treatment, and face heightened mental health challenges. To address these challenges, targeted mental health and medication adherence interventions have been developed, including in Tanzania, which is home to 6% of the world's YPLWH. This study proposes a mathematical model to estimate the health and economic outcomes of mental health HIV adherence interventions targeting YPLWH in Tanzania.We developed a Markov model to predict the long-term health (Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALY)) and economic outcomes (Value of a Statistical Life Year (VLSY)) of mental health HIV adherence interventions targeting YPLWH. We parameterized the model using outcomes data from the 2016-2020 Sauti ya Vijana randomized control trial (RCT) conducted in Moshi, Tanzania. Cost data were retrieved from a cost analysis of the same RCT and supplemented with data from published literature. The study is conducted from a health payer’s perspective, and the Willingness-To-Pay (WTP) per DALY averted was set to the 2021 Tanzanian GDP per capita (USD 1099.3). Costs and outcomes were modeled for ten years and discounted at an annual rate of 3%. The findings suggest that the Sauti ya Vijana intervention modeled in this study is cost-effective at a WTP of USD 1099.3. The Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for the intervention compared to the standard of care was USD 637.06 per DALY averted at a 3% discount rate. The benefit-to-cost ratio of the intervention was USD 26.54 in economic productivity for the intervention arm for every dollar spent on the intervention, and the net economic productivity benefit was USD 17,174.74 over a decade. Mental health adherence interventions hold the promise of improving health outcomes amongst YPLWH. The mathematical model developed in this study is a valuable decision-making tool for policymakers regarding mental health adherence interventions targeting YPLWH in Tanzania. The model contributes to the global goal of achieving the UNAIDS 95-95-95 targets for YPLWH.
Item Open Access Development of an Interactive Global Surgery Course for Interdisciplinary Learners.(Annals of global health, 2021-03) Fitzgerald, Tamara N; Muma, Nyagetuba JK; Gallis, John A; Reavis, Grey; Ukachukwu, Alvan; Smith, Emily R; Ogbuoji, Osondu; Rice, Henry EIntroduction
Global surgical care is increasingly recognized in the global health agenda and requires multidisciplinary engagement. Despite high interest among medical students, residents and other learners, many surgical faculty and health experts remain uniformed about global surgical care.Methods
We have operated an interdisciplinary graduate-level course in Global Surgical Care based on didactics and interactive group learning. Students completed a pre- and post-course survey regarding their learning experiences and results were analyzed using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test.Results
Fourteen students completed the pre-course survey, and 11 completed the post-course survey. Eleven students (79%) were enrolled in a Master's degree program in global health, with eight students (57%) planning to attend medical school. The median ranking of surgery on the global health agenda was fifth at the beginning of the course and third at the conclusion (p = 0.11). Non-infectious disease priorities tended to stay the same or increase in rank from pre- to post-course. Infectious disease priorities tended to decrease in rank (HIV/AIDS, p = 0.07; malaria, p = 0.02; neglected infectious disease, p = 0.3). Students reported that their understanding of global health (p = 0.03), global surgery (p = 0.001) and challenges faced by the underserved (p = 0.03) improved during the course. When asked if surgery was an indispensable part of healthcare, before the course 64% of students strongly agreed, while after the course 91% of students strongly agreed (p = 0.3). Students reported that the interactive nature of the course strengthened their skills in collaborative problem-solving.Conclusions
We describe an interdisciplinary global surgery course that integrates didactics with team-based projects. Students appeared to learn core topics and held a different view of global surgery after the course. Similar courses in global surgery can educate clinicians and other stakeholders about strategies for building healthy surgical systems worldwide.Item Open Access Investigating Nigeria’s Progress Towards Self-financing: Political economy analysis of routine immunization vaccines financing(2024) Edom, Mary Winifred UgonmaBackground: Globally, about five million children under the age of five years old die each year, of which Nigeria accounts for roughly eight hundred and fifty thousand. Despite the alarming number of deaths, persistent financial barriers hinder immunization efforts, with a central focus on the low budgetary allocation for routine immunization, which fosters a dependence on external funding and a lack of attention to developing sustainable domestic financing strategies. Methods: I conducted a problem-driven political economy analysis to explore the interplay between political dynamics, economic considerations, and internal and external contextual factors that impact Nigeria's ability to sustainably finance vaccines beyond its partnership with Gavi. This PEA involved 14 key informant interviews across actors from national government organizations, developmental partners, and civil society organizations. Results: I found that a significant challenge in the vaccine payment pathway arose from delayed approval and release of funds. Furthermore, participants identified other central challenges to vaccine financing including the lack of prioritization by the government, limited fiscal space, and Nigeria’s adverse macroeconomic conditions such as currency devaluation and high debt financing. To tackle some of the challenges, participants reported that exhaustive stakeholder engagement, enhanced state government involvement in decision-making, excise taxes, private sector involvement via local vaccine manufacturing, and internal accountability by CSOs and private entities were some opportunities for change. Conclusions: These findings underscore the need for robust institutional processes to streamline and optimize vaccine financing mechanisms. Furthermore, comprehensive engagement and representation across all stakeholder groups are imperative to foster ownership and commitment to immunization initiatives. Addressing the identified challenges in the vaccine financing landscape would ensure the sustainability of the National Program on Immunization and drive improvements in public health outcomes.
Item Open Access Strategic donor behaviour and country vulnerability in health aid transitions.(BMJ global health, 2023-11) Mao, Wenhui; McDade, Kaci Kennedy; Ogbuoji, Osondu; Yamey, Gavin; Bermeo, Sarah BlodgettBackground
When countries reach the middle-income threshold, many multilateral donors, including Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance (Gavi), begin to withdraw their official development assistance (ODA), known as graduation. We hypothesised that bilateral donors might follow Gavi's lead, except in countries where they have strategic interests. We aim to understand how bilateral donors behave after a recipient country graduates from Gavi support and how bilateral donors might treat Gavi support countries differently, based on 'strategic interest'. We also aim to identify countries that were more vulnerable to 'simultaneous' transitions and financial cliffs after Gavi transition.Methods
This is an observational dyadic analysis using longitudinal data. We collected country-level data on 77 Gavi-eligible countries between 2009 and 2018 and paired donor and recipient country in a specific year to conduct dyadic analysis. We included Gavi graduation status and Gavi disbursement as explanatory variables. We controlled for (1) donor-recipient relationship variables that represent potential strategic relationships (eg, distance between donor and recipient country) and (2) recipient-level characteristics (eg, population, income). We used Odinary Least Squares regression, Tobit and two-part model in Stata SE 15.0.Findings
We found a country would receive $3.1 million less all sector ODA from a bilateral donor, and $0.6 million less health ODA, after they graduate from Gavi. For every additional 1% ODA a country would receive from Gavi, it would receive 0.14% more ODA and 0.16% more health ODA from individual bilateral donors. Gavi's graduation status or disbursement brought more change in percentage term to health ODA than to total ODA. Additionally, Gavi's graduation was observed to have a larger negative impact on bilateral ODA in the longer term. Countries that sent more migrants, had been colonised, and received more US military assistance tended to receive more ODA. There are similarities and differences across different donors and bilateral donors tend to provide more ODA to nearby countries and countries receiving fewer exports from the donor. We found that former colonies did not see a decline in aid after Gavi graduation.Conclusion
Bilateral donors behave in a similar manner to Gavi when it comes to funding health systems in low and middle-income countries. Therefore, some countries may be at risk of losing donor resources for health from a multitude of sources around the same time. However, countries that have a strategic interest in bilateral donors may be spared from such funding cliffs. This research has important implications for global health donors' funding policies and approaches in addition to recipient countries' transition planning.Item Open Access Strategies to Scale-Up Global Access and Uptake of Hearing Screening: A Systematic Review(2023-04-18) Cionfolo, HaleyI. ABSTRACT Introduction: Although interventions to address hearing loss exist, access is inequitably distributed across geographic, socioeconomic, and racial axes globally. We sought to determine which scale-up strategies could be useful to bolster the uptake of hearing screening to reduce the global burden of hearing loss. We then provide targeted policy recommendations to aid the implementation of these strategies. Methods: After evaluating articles from five databases using our inclusion/exclusion criteria, we extracted qualitative and statistical evidence related to the uptake of neonatal, child, and adult hearing screening (NHS, CHS, and AHS), specifically their use, adherence, and satisfaction. Two reviewers independently assessed article quality using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (2018). We then categorized and compared the success of interventions. Results: Of the 225 articles screened, 29 studies fit our inclusion criteria. Of the 29 articles, 18 describe findings targeting NHS scale-up interventions, five CHS, four AHS, one NHS/CHS, and one CHS/AHS. Interventions assessed were educational (n=3), policy and systemic (n=3), telehealth (n=2), financial and funding (n=2), expanded screening (n=6), and restructured screening programs (n=7). The evidence from these articles suggests that restructure screening programs, the most documented intervention type, could be the most effective in increasing uptake generally and across HIC and UMIC settings, with no null results. Discussion: We recommend policies and interventions that restructure screening programs or expand their reach as strong options to allocate resources toward in both high- and low-resource settings, relative to existing intervention types previously attempted. More research pertaining to scale-up, especially in lower-income settings, is necessary, however, to make the most appropriate recommendations.Item Embargo Understanding Determinants of Mortality in Preterm Infants: A Mixed Methods Study(2024) Miraj, FatimaBackground: Prematurity is the leading cause of child deaths, accounting for >30% of neonatal (first 28 days) deaths globally. Social determinants, defined as the social, economic, geographic, and environmental conditions of individuals, play an important role in shaping a preterm infant’s health outcome and their likelihood of survival. However, there remains a gap in understanding the extent to which these determinants impact a preterm infant’s survival. There is also a dearth of evidence to evaluate the effectiveness of the current policies and programs that determine the kind of care provided to newborns, particularly preterm babies. This study aimed to identify determinants (infant, social and demographic, and mother's reproductive and behavioral, country-level factors) of mortality in preterm infants. Methods: This was a mixed-methods study with two parts: 1) Quantitative and 2) Qualitative. The quantitative part consisted of analyzing data from the Demographic Health Survey (DHS) to identify main determinants of survival of preterm babies born in low- and -middle income countries (LMICs). A multilevel mixed-effects survival analysis was performed to find the association of these determinants with mortality in preterm infants within the first 7, 30, 365 days of life. To delve deeper into the country-level factors, qualitative interviews were conducted with policymakers to understand their perspective on the issue of newborn and preterm infant health in one of the selected LMICs, Ethiopia. Interviews were analyzed using thematic analysis. All analysis was performed using Stata version 17 and NVivo version 14. Results: A total of 16,539 preterm births were recorded, within which 1,742 deaths occurred in the first 7 days, 2,036 deaths occurred in the first 30 days, and 2,367 occurred in the first year of life. Being born female (7 days HR: 0.672, CI: 0.602 - 0.750), urban residence (7 days HR = 0.754, CI: 0.627 - 0.907), birth interval of between 24- and 60-months (7 days HR = 0.508, CI: 0.419 - 0.617), breastfeeding (7 days HR: 0.008, CI: 0.005 - 0.011), and higher pregnancy duration (gestational age) of the mother (HR: 0.457, CI: 0.424 - 0.493) were associated with a lower risk of death. Small birthweight babies had a higher risk of death (7 days HR: 1.484, CI: 1.893 - 3.322). The HR for all determinants remained similar for death at 7 days, 30 days, and 365 days. Evidence for within and across country variation was also found, indicating unobserved factors at the country and primary sampling unit level that contribute to differences in mortality among preterm children. Qualitative findings showed that despite a strong national policy for preterm care, critical gaps persist – regional disparities, rural-urban divides, inadequate health infrastructure, budget constraints, limited access to care, low community awareness, and a shortage of skilled professionals hinder effective policy implementation in Ethiopia. International collaboration, increased financial investment, human resource development, and enhanced healthcare infrastructure is required to bolster preterm infant survival outcomes in Ethiopia. Conclusions: This study’s findings highlight the significance of factors such as infant characteristics, social and demographic determinants, and maternal behaviors in influencing survival outcomes and emphasize the need for targeted interventions to address gender disparities, promote breastfeeding practices, and improve access to healthcare services. An alignment between policy development and execution is required to see the effectiveness of efforts done to improve preterm infant health in LMIC settings.
Item Open Access Universal Health Coverage for the Poor and Informal Sector in Africa: A Health Financing Policy Analysis(2022) Hughes, Michelle ZoeBackground:In their pursuit of Universal Health Coverage (UHC), a challenge African countries face is extending health coverage to the poor and informal sector. This group accounts for a significant proportion of the population in most African countries, yet there is a wealth of evidence documenting their low health coverage and a contrasting paucity of data available to inform financing policy reform. This thesis intends to collect and apply data to this challenge, redressing this paucity and generating evidence on policies that support a fair, progressive realization of UHC.
Methods:I used a policy surveillance methodology to transform the text of health financing laws and policies into quantitative and qualitative data for analysis. I surveyed the 47 countries of the World Health Organization AFRO region with a codebook consisting of 28 questions relating to the coverage of the poor and informal sector. I answered questions using publicly available, country level documents. I used the data to (i) identify prevailing financing policies that provide health coverage to the poor and informal sector and (ii) present a comparative case analysis examining associations between health financing policies and essential health service coverage.
Results:Health insurance and user fees are predominant UHC financing approaches in Africa. 45 of 47 countries (96%) have health insurance policy and 34 countries (72%) have policy enforcing user fees. To help the poor and informal sector overcome these financial access barriers, countries use exemptions and subsidies. Of the 45 countries with health insurance, 18 (40%) exempt or subsidise premiums for the poor. Of the 34 countries with user fees, 18 (53%) exempt and/or subsidise user fees for the poor. Of the 41 countries with health service packages, 19 countries (46%) provide the health services for free. In general, there is a lack of targeted financing mechanisms for the informal sector.
Conclusions:Extending coverage to the poor and informal sector is a challenge within the broader context of expanding UHC in Africa. This study provides a comprehensive overview of financing policy solutions from within the continent and lays the foundation for further analyses to clarify what reforms work best.