Browsing by Author "Van Dover, Cindy L"
Results Per Page
Sort Options
Item Open Access A strategy for the conservation of biodiversity on mid-ocean ridges from deep-sea mining.(Science advances, 2018-07-04) Dunn, Daniel C; Van Dover, Cindy L; Etter, Ron J; Smith, Craig R; Levin, Lisa A; Morato, Telmo; Colaço, Ana; Dale, Andrew C; Gebruk, Andrey V; Gjerde, Kristina M; Halpin, Patrick N; Howell, Kerry L; Johnson, David; Perez, José Angel A; Ribeiro, Marta Chantal; Stuckas, Heiko; Weaver, Philip; SEMPIA Workshop ParticipantsMineral exploitation has spread from land to shallow coastal waters and is now planned for the offshore, deep seabed. Large seafloor areas are being approved for exploration for seafloor mineral deposits, creating an urgent need for regional environmental management plans. Networks of areas where mining and mining impacts are prohibited are key elements of these plans. We adapt marine reserve design principles to the distinctive biophysical environment of mid-ocean ridges, offer a framework for design and evaluation of these networks to support conservation of benthic ecosystems on mid-ocean ridges, and introduce projected climate-induced changes in the deep sea to the evaluation of reserve design. We enumerate a suite of metrics to measure network performance against conservation targets and network design criteria promulgated by the Convention on Biological Diversity. We apply these metrics to network scenarios on the northern and equatorial Mid-Atlantic Ridge, where contractors are exploring for seafloor massive sulfide (SMS) deposits. A latitudinally distributed network of areas performs well at (i) capturing ecologically important areas and 30 to 50% of the spreading ridge areas, (ii) replicating representative areas, (iii) maintaining along-ridge population connectivity, and (iv) protecting areas potentially less affected by climate-related changes. Critically, the network design is adaptive, allowing for refinement based on new knowledge and the location of mining sites, provided that design principles and conservation targets are maintained. This framework can be applied along the global mid-ocean ridge system as a precautionary measure to protect biodiversity and ecosystem function from impacts of SMS mining.Item Open Access Amplicon sequencing of 42 nuclear loci supports directional gene flow between South Pacific populations of a hydrothermal vent limpet.(Ecology and evolution, 2019-06) Plouviez, Sophie; LaBella, Abigail Leavitt; Weisrock, David W; von Meijenfeldt, FA Bastiaan; Ball, Bernard; Neigel, Joseph E; Van Dover, Cindy LIn the past few decades, population genetics and phylogeographic studies have improved our knowledge of connectivity and population demography in marine environments. Studies of deep-sea hydrothermal vent populations have identified barriers to gene flow, hybrid zones, and demographic events, such as historical population expansions and contractions. These deep-sea studies, however, used few loci, which limit the amount of information they provided for coalescent analysis and thus our ability to confidently test complex population dynamics scenarios. In this study, we investigated population structure, demographic history, and gene flow directionality among four Western Pacific hydrothermal vent populations of the vent limpet Lepetodrilus aff. schrolli. These vent sites are located in the Manus and Lau back-arc basins, currently of great interest for deep-sea mineral extraction. A total of 42 loci were sequenced from each individual using high-throughput amplicon sequencing. Amplicon sequences were analyzed using both genetic variant clustering methods and evolutionary coalescent approaches. Like most previously investigated vent species in the South Pacific, L. aff. schrolli showed no genetic structure within basins but significant differentiation between basins. We inferred significant directional gene flow from Manus Basin to Lau Basin, with low to no gene flow in the opposite direction. This study is one of the very few marine population studies using >10 loci for coalescent analysis and serves as a guide for future marine population studies.Item Open Access Beyond the Edge of the Sea: Educational Programming for a Marine Science Art Exhibit Grades K-12(2008-04-25T03:30:52Z) Bostock, VirginiaThe ocean is the largest biosphere on earth covering about 70% of the earth’s surface. Yet, very little is known about this deep sea environment due to its inaccessibility. The task of educating the public about deep ocean environments and making people care about them is no easy job. One team made up of a hydrothermal vent scientist and a watercolor artist have come together in a collaborative effort that will covey the beauty, awareness and understanding of the deep sea. The format for displaying information will be a traveling art exhibit that showcases illustrations of deep sea environments and the communities that live there. The specific objective of my master’s project was to produce museum programming for grades K-12 to accompany the exhibit, in order to promote ocean education and awareness of chemosynthetic communities. Upon completion the lesson plans will be posted on the Muscarelle Museum of Art web site, providing educators access to educational materials before arrival at the exhibit. The published activities will be correlated to the National Science standards published by the National Research Council and Ocean Literacy standards. The anticipated response is for students to be inspired by and aware of the deep-sea and the amazing life that is found there. By recognizing the existence of deep sea organisms, individuals may become stewards for them and their environment. Each set of activities follow a standard lesson plan format and include: summary, background information, objective, setting, duration, materials, standards, materials and In addition, all lessons follow the interactive museum experience model, a guide for developing education programs in settings like museums.Item Open Access Climate Adaptation in North Carolina: Assessing Coastal Habitat for Natural Shoreline Stabilization(2012-04-23) Carlozo, NicoleClimate change threatens our natural coastlines with sea level rise and increased levels of erosion. Although various solutions exist for these climate-induced threats, shoreline protection is the favored solution along North Carolina coasts. Currently, debate surrounds the use of unnatural engineered shoreline protection structures. Alternatively, natural stabilization methods have been suggested to protect shores while providing ecosystem services. Conservation organizations, such as The Nature Conservancy, are interested in protecting threatened lands through natural stabilization methods. Oyster reef and submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV) restoration represent two natural stabilization techniques. However, prior to project implementation, potential restoration sites must be identified. This study reviews North Carolina shoreline stabilization policies and identifies suitable oyster and SAV restoration sites. Habitat suitability indices were developed for Dare and Hyde county estuaries through ArcMap GIS spatial analysis and NOAA’s Wave Exposure Model. Overall, less than 5% of the study area is suitable for eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica) restoration while about 14-15% is suitable for widgeon grass (Ruppia maritima) and shoal grass (Halodule wrightii) restoration. Suitable eelgrass (Zostera marina) restoration sites were also identified, but widgeon and shoal grass restoration potential was highest. Spatial analyses and previous shoreline erosion studies were used to recommend priority restoration sites. Managers are encouraged to identify critical conservation areas, promote living shorelines where applicable, communicate with stakeholders, and support living shoreline permit development. Although this study specifically informs The Nature Conservancy’s Coastal Climate Adaptation Project, the results are relevant to all coastal stakeholders.Item Open Access Closing the liability gap: A review of liability alternatives in environmental regulation for the emerging seafloor mineral extraction industry(2016-04-27) Hoyt, SarahThe potential for vast mineral wealth on the seafloor has led to the emergence of commercial interest in recent decades. A critical barrier to seafloor mineral development has been the lack of regulatory regime for commercial exploitation, which would address how mining entities are to monitor or be monitored, manage or be managed, and compensate for potential adverse environmental impacts. Seafloor minerals that occur in the area beyond national jurisdiction (the Area) are governed by the International Seabed Authority (ISA). The ISA and stakeholders recognize that unknown impacts and even unknown consequences of foreseen impacts to the seabed and pelagic ecosystems may present an environmental liability gap, which may unnecessarily increase environmental risk exposure to the ISA. This paper presents an analysis in an effort to support the ISA in its work to minimize the potential for a liability gap in seafloor mineral exploitation in the Area. It develops a structured review of regulatory alternatives, bonds and insurance, that have been implemented in established industries that exhibit similar operational and liability characteristics to seafloor mineral extraction, and offers a decision pathway to support ISA efforts to reduce environmental risk exposure.Item Open Access Environmental Features Relevant to Deep-Sea Mining along the Rio Grande Rise for the Implementation of Protected Areas(2017-04-28) Smith, AustinInterest in the extraction of mineral resources from the deep-sea has increased rapidly in the recent years due to technological advancements. Since 2001, the International Seabed Authority has granted over 25 exploration leases for deep-sea mining in oceanic Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction. These areas are often poorly studied and thus it is currently a challenge to develop effective regulations before mining activities commence. This study attempts to address this issue by exploring the environmental characteristics found in an emergent area of deep-sea mining exploration, the Rio Grande Rise (RGR) off the Southeastern coast of Brazil. This is accomplished through the compilation and mapping of environmental datasets for the RGR region as well as a biogeographic classification of the RGR seafloor based on several datasets that are known to influence deep-sea biodiversity. The goal of this study is to identify areas and features within this region that are important for regulators to consider as mining regulations and protected areas are developed in the near future.Item Open Access Environmentally Friendly Aids to Navigation Buoy Moorings(2015-04-23) Slivinski, LukeAids to navigation (ATON) established and maintained by the United States Coast Guard (USCG) negatively impact coral and a seagrass species listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). These negative impacts are caused by physical contact between the threatened species or the benthic environment surrounding them and the ATON itself, the ATON’s mooring, or the temporary anchoring/mooring devices employed by the USCG vessels installing and maintaining the ATON. These interactions constitute a “take” under the ESA and are detrimental to the health and vitality of those species. The USCG should explore practicable new ATON mooring technologies and installation and maintenance procedures that eliminate or lessen negative impacts on the threatened seagrass and coral species. This paper focuses on USCG ATON impacts to threatened seagrass and coral species and includes: a characterization and quantification of USCG ATON impact areas in critical seagrass and coral habitats; and an analysis of novel (to the USCG) and more environmentally-friendly commercial-off-the-shelf anchoring and mooring systems suitable for USCG ATON, including an analysis of their installation and maintenance requirements and a cost comparison between them and traditional ATON anchoring and mooring systems.Item Open Access Improving Regulation of Deep-Sea Mining Environmental Impact Assessments(2023-04-28) Kuesel, JessicaIn recent years, deep-sea mining in the Area, “the seabed and ocean floor and subsoil thereof, beyond the limits of national jurisdiction” (UNCLOS, 1982, art. 1 ¶ 1(1)), has garnered increasing attention as a potential method of obtaining scarce minerals needed for clean technologies. However, as interest has grown, so have concerns about the environmental impacts that will result from the development of an extractive industry within sensitive deep-sea environments. Environmental impact assessments (EIAs) have emerged as key tools for identifying, evaluating, and minimizing environmental impacts from deep-sea mining activities. International best practice identifies a general framework for conducting effective EIAs. First, a proposed activity undergoes screening to determine whether an EIA must be conducted. If an EIA is required, the scoping stage identifies the range and extent of environmental impacts that will be addressed in the assessment. Once scoping is complete, the project proponent conducts an environmental analysis, often with reference to threshold values that identify limits on the amount of environmental harm a project may cause, and documents its analysis in a draft environmental impact statement (EIS). Baseline studies, which identify the environmental conditions that exist in a project area before the project’s start, are essential for informing this report. Next, the draft EIS undergoes expert review. Draft EISs are also subject to a stakeholder consultation process, which may occur at the scoping stage, after the draft EIS is submitted, or after expert review. Once the expert review and stakeholder consultation are complete, the regulator makes a final decision about whether the activity may proceed. After an EIS’s approval, the regulator performs follow-up measures to ensure compliance with the EIA. Additionally, many regulators provide an opportunity to appeal decisions made during the EIA process and on final EISs. Notably, an EIA process requires a relatively high level of institutional capacity to be effective, as it relies heavily on experts, and benefits from high levels of transparency. The International Seabed Authority (ISA) is currently developing a Mining Code to govern exploration and exploitation of deep-sea minerals in the Area. Within the code, EIAs are essential tools for the ISA to fulfill its explicit responsibility under the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) to effectively protect the marine environment. As such, both the exploration and exploitation regimes include provisions either requiring or recommending the conduct of EIAs, with the Legal and Technical Commission reviewing EISs prepared under both regimes. Even so, these provisions have been subject to critique, particularly in light of recent ISA approvals of EISs under the exploration regime. This study identifies a range of disparate recommendations to improve the EIA process under the ISA’s Mining Code and outlines areas of consensus among them. To conduct this research, I first completed a literature review of existing scholarship on the ISA’s EIA process. I then conducted semi-structured interviews with scientific, regulatory, and legal experts who have expertise related to the deep-sea environment and/or deep-sea mining. The literature review and interviews outlined many recommendations to improve the EIA process for deep-sea mining under the ISA’s exploration and exploitation regimes. These recommendations were divided into the following categories: 1. Legal and Technical Commission: (a) LTC composition and capacity, (b) Expert consultation by the LTC, (c) Relationship between the LTC and the proponent, (d) Additional factors impacting the capacity of the LTC, and (e) LTC decision-making and transparency; 2. Environmental information and threshold values: (a) General environmental policy, (b) Baseline studies, and (c) Threshold values; 3. Stakeholder consultation: (a) Defining stakeholders, (b) Adequacy of consultation, (c) Timing of consultation within the process, (d) Response to comments; and 4. Additional factors influencing the EIA process: (a) Monitoring and adaptive management, (b) Opportunity to appeal. While the recommendations touch each part of the EIA process, they center around four central themes: (1) addressing uncertainty regarding the nature and operations of the developing deep-sea mining industry and its potential impacts on the environment, (2) increasing transparency about the EIA process and the substance of EISs, (3) increasing LTC capacity to review and evaluate EISs, and (4) strengthening the roles of the regulator and external stakeholders in the EIA process. Additionally, the recommendations illustrate similarities in the ways to bolster the EIA process under both the exploration and exploitation regimes.Item Open Access Population Genetics of Species Associated with Deep-sea Hydrothermal Vents in the Western Pacific(2012) Thaler, Andrew DavidGenetic diversity, population structure, and connectivity influence interactions among communities and populations. At hydrothermal vents in the western pacific, population structure in vent-associated species could occur at spatial scales ranging from vent sites separated by a few hundred meters to oceanic basins separated by more than 3000 kilometers. The spatial scale of population structure has important conservation implications; species that are well-connected across large geographic regions are more resilient to natural and anthropogenic disturbance. This dissertation examines the genetic diversity, population structure, and connectivity of 3 vent-associated species in the western Pacific. It first presents results from the development of microsatellite primers for Ifremeria nautilei, a deep-sea vent associated snail, then uses mitochondrial COI sequences and a suite of microsatellite markers to examine the broader connectivity of three vent-associated species, Ifremeria nautilei, Chorocaris sp. 2, and Olgasolaris tollmanni, across three back-arc basins in the western Pacific.
Within Manus Basin, no significant genetic differentiation was detected in populations of Ifremeria nautilei (based on COI and microsatellite), Chorocaris sp. 2 (based on COI and microsatellite), or Olgasolaris tollmanni (based on COI). A previously documented low-abundance cryptic species, Chorocaris sp. 1, was detected from a single site, South Su (based on COI). The population of I. nautilei in Manus Basin was found to be significantly differentiated from a second population that appeared to be panmictic across North Fiji and Lau Basin (based on COI and microsatellites). Chorocaris sp. 2 was also found to be significantly differentiated between Manus and North Fiji Basin (based on COI). Both I. nautilei and Chorocaris sp. 2 showed signs of potential low-level migration between Manus and other southwestern Pacific basins. O. tollmanni was undifferentiated between Manus and Lau Basin (based on COI). It is likely that a variable impedance filter exists that limits the realized dispersal of some, but not all species between Manus Basin and other western Pacific back-arc basins. The presence of a variable filter has implications for the conservation and management of hydrothermal vents in Manus Basin, as it is unclear what effects sustained anthropogenic disturbance will have on isolated populations of I. nautilei and Chorocaris sp. 2.
Item Open Access Sources, Quality, and Fate of Organic Matter in Deep-Sea Sediments in the Larsen A Embayment, Weddell Sea: Changes by Global Warming and Ice Shelf Melt(2016) Shimizu, Megumi SIce shelf coverage in Antarctica is declining due to recent global warming. The northern part of Larsen Ice Shelf, the Larsen A in the Weddell Sea, has been decreasing since the 19th century and in 2000 finally disappeared. Ice shelf coverage decrease should dramatically enhance biological productivity in surface water and organic matter flux to the seafloor. This dissertation examines sources of organic matter to sediments, indicators of labile organic matter flux increase due to the ice-shelf collapse, and potential subsequent impacts of changing ocean productivity on the sedimentary microbial community in the sediment cores taken across a 170-year chronoseries of ice-shelf loss, five-transect stations. Characterizing lipid biomarkers, phytoplankton (rather than terrestrially derived organic material) was identified as the major source of organic matter in the sediments, as previously found in other nearshore Antarctic regions. The predominance of C16, C18, and C20 fatty acids, 24-methylenecholesterol, sitosterol, and 13C-enriched sea-ice diatom biomarker (C25:2 HBIs) indicate the importance of organic matter inputs from sea-ice diatom communities that become more dominant as the prevalence of sea ice coverage once the ice shelf disappears. Bacterial and Archaeal lipids were second and third largest lipid sources. These lipids could be sourced from the water column and in situ production as well as former ice shelf and ice-rafted debris. Using the vertical lipid distributions, diagenetic models were applied to estimate the pelagic lipid flux before and after the ice shelf collapse. The results suggest that the rapid increase in flux due to the ice shelf disintegration, but further characterization of degradation rates need to be undertaken to increase confidence in the magnitude of this increased flux. Lipid flux increase may induce a shift in the microbial community structure in the sediments. Multivariate analyses identified that the organic matter content and δ13CTOC values, relative abundances of labile and recalcitrant lipid biomarkers, and concentrations of nitrogen species are important factors that correlate with downcore and cross-shelf microbial community composition. Enriched organic matter content (electron donor) may influence the microbial community through the decreased availability of electron acceptors in the sediments. The quality of the organic matter may also influence the microbial community: microbes that use recalcitrant organic matter shift to phytodetritus degraders as more-labile organic matter is delivered to the seabed following ice-shelf collapse. These results will offer a new perspective on the potential impacts of the ice-shelf disintegration to the subseafloor environment. Further investigations are needed to quantify the flux increase and microbial degradation rates of organic matter to expand the knowledge on influences of glacier melt on biogeochemical cycle.
Item Open Access The Importance of Biodiversity in Deep-Sea Chemosynthetic Ecosystems: An Assessment of Ecosystem Functioning and Services(2019) Turner, Phillip JohnAs demand for deep-sea resources increases, understanding the non-extractive use values and ecosystem services associated with the deep sea is crucial. A broader understanding of the benefits provided by deep-sea ecosystems will demonstrate why humanity should have a vested interest in the health of the deep sea, and encourage decision makers to enact sustainable environmental management plans. This dissertation contributes to the literature connecting deep-sea ecosystem structures, functions and services, with a focus on hydrothermal vents and methane seeps.
Part 1 uses a repetitive survey technique to explore the views of deep-sea stakeholders on the importance of rare-species research and the ecological importance of rare species. Overall, participants called for research that addresses deep-sea biodiversity as a whole (i.e., both rare and abundant species) but opposing opinions existed regarding the ecological importance of rare species. Opinion ranged from the acknowledgment that rare species may play important roles now or in the future to the viewpoint that, by definition, rare species play minor roles in the ecosystem. The opposing opinions likely correspond to a lack of knowledge concerning the role of rare deep-sea species in ecosystem functioning.
Part 2 uses functional trait analysis to assess the contribution of rare and common species to hydrothermal vent food-web dynamics. Some rare and common species were found to possess individually unique trait combinations and to contribute to hydrothermal vent functional diversity. In addition, trait combinations were found to vary among vent sites within the same biogeographic region, highlighting the ecological heterogeneity of hydrothermal vent systems. Part 2 suggests that both rare and common species should be incorporated into environmental management planning and that, given the uncertainty regarding species distributions and population connectivity, ensuring the persistence of functionally distinct rare species may require all active hydrothermal vents to be protected from deep-sea mining impacts.
Part 3 uses phototransects to characterize the epibenthic megafauna at seeps on the US Atlantic margin. Epibenthic megafauna were found to follow depth-related patterns in taxon-abundance, suggesting a faunal boundary exists between shallow (~400m) and deep (~1500m) seeps. Part 3 also uses stable isotope analysis, plankton samples and observational data to explore the importance of seeps to the life history of the commercially valuable deep-sea red crab (Chaceon quinquedens). Chemosynthetically derived carbon was found to contribute up to ~50% of nutrition to individual crabs, although the proportion was variable among individuals and seeps. At Chincoteague seep, dense aggregations (~15 individuals 10m-2) of red crab were observed, alongside fifteen mating pairs, three ovigerous females and numerous zoeal larvae; suggesting some seeps may act as a reproductive hotspot as well as food resource for red crab populations.
Part 4 highlights a cultural connection to the deep sea, whereby the Atlantic seabed is considered the final resting place for ~1.8 million enslaved Africans who died during slaving voyages from Africa to the Americas. Part 4 asks that the International Seabed Authority, ahead of mineral extraction from hydrothermal vent deposits on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, to consider ways to commemorate the Middle Passage in the Area Beyond National Jurisdiction and recognize that cultural artifacts relating to the transatlantic slave trade may be found during mining-related activities.
Item Open Access Using Social Network Analysis to Identify Communication Patterns among Albemarle-Pamlico National Estuary Partnership Partners(2013-04-26) Brogan, KatherineAs one of the original “estuaries of national significance” designated by the Clean Water Act of 1987, the Albemarle-Pamlico National Estuary Partnership (APNEP) works to protect and restore the valuable resources of one of the largest estuary systems on the Atlantic coast. In order to accomplish its mission with a limited budget, APNEP engages in cooperative projects with partners from federal and state government agencies, environmental non-profits, academic institutions, and municipal planners. As APNEP moves forward with the implementation of its 2012 Comprehensive Conservation and Management Plan, communicating with existing partners, accessing potential partner organizations, and encouraging information sharing between environmental professionals in the region is crucial to efficiently accomplishing management plan objectives. In order to assess how APNEP interacts with its partners and the larger environmental community in the Albemarle-Pamlico watershed region, a social network analysis was developed to map individuals and organizations that regularly communicate about environmental issues in the area. Using snowball survey methodology to identify individuals and organizations that are involved in watershed management issues, regional social network maps were created using the statistics program R. The social network maps include representations of communication links between sectors, network connectedness, the relative importance of specific individuals within the network, and a geographic representation of the connections between environmental professionals in the region. Analysis of the network maps identified geographical and organizational gaps in APNEP’s outreach efforts, as well as key individuals whose network position could be leveraged to improve the efficiency of information transfer among the larger network. The structure of the various network maps provided implicit recommendations for APNEP to improve its outreach efforts to establish new partnerships and exchange information with the regional environmental community. As a long-term project, social network analysis can help APNEP target its limited communications resources to increase collaboration and share information efficiently with stakeholders.