Browsing by Subject "Glaucoma"
Results Per Page
Sort Options
Item Open Access Angiopoietin receptor TEK mutations underlie primary congenital glaucoma with variable expressivity.(The Journal of clinical investigation, 2016-07) Souma, Tomokazu; Tompson, Stuart W; Thomson, Benjamin R; Siggs, Owen M; Kizhatil, Krishnakumar; Yamaguchi, Shinji; Feng, Liang; Limviphuvadh, Vachiranee; Whisenhunt, Kristina N; Maurer-Stroh, Sebastian; Yanovitch, Tammy L; Kalaydjieva, Luba; Azmanov, Dimitar N; Finzi, Simone; Mauri, Lucia; Javadiyan, Shahrbanou; Souzeau, Emmanuelle; Zhou, Tiger; Hewitt, Alex W; Kloss, Bethany; Burdon, Kathryn P; Mackey, David A; Allen, Keri F; Ruddle, Jonathan B; Lim, Sing-Hui; Rozen, Steve; Tran-Viet, Khanh-Nhat; Liu, Xiaorong; John, Simon; Wiggs, Janey L; Pasutto, Francesca; Craig, Jamie E; Jin, Jing; Quaggin, Susan E; Young, Terri LPrimary congenital glaucoma (PCG) is a devastating eye disease and an important cause of childhood blindness worldwide. In PCG, defects in the anterior chamber aqueous humor outflow structures of the eye result in elevated intraocular pressure (IOP); however, the genes and molecular mechanisms involved in the etiology of these defects have not been fully characterized. Previously, we observed PCG-like phenotypes in transgenic mice that lack functional angiopoietin-TEK signaling. Herein, we identified rare TEK variants in 10 of 189 unrelated PCG families and demonstrated that each mutation results in haploinsufficiency due to protein loss of function. Multiple cellular mechanisms were responsible for the loss of protein function resulting from individual TEK variants, including an absence of normal protein production, protein aggregate formation, enhanced proteasomal degradation, altered subcellular localization, and reduced responsiveness to ligand stimulation. Further, in mice, hemizygosity for Tek led to the formation of severely hypomorphic Schlemm's canal and trabecular meshwork, as well as elevated IOP, demonstrating that anterior chamber vascular development is sensitive to Tek gene dosage and the resulting decrease in angiopoietin-TEK signaling. Collectively, these results identify TEK mutations in patients with PCG that likely underlie disease and are transmitted in an autosomal dominant pattern with variable expressivity.Item Open Access Deep Learning to Predict Glaucoma Progression using Structural Changes in the Eye(2024) Mandal, SayanGlaucoma is a group of chronic eye diseases characterized by optic neuropathy, which causes irreversible vision loss. It is caused by progressive degeneration of the optic nerve, leading to gradual loss of the visual field from the periphery to the center, resulting in blindness if left untreated. Since the changes are gradual and the damage progresses generally slowly, glaucoma development is insidious and often diagnosed until it reaches an advanced stage. Early detection of glaucoma progression is necessary to monitor the atrophy and formulate treatment strategies to halt progressive functional vision impairments. The availability of data centric methods have made it possible for researchers to develop computer-aided algorithms for the clinical diagnosis of glaucoma and capture accurate disease characteristics. In this research, we use deep learning models, one such forefront, to identify complex disease characteristics and progression criteria, enabling the detection of subtle changes indicative of glaucoma progression.
To this end, we investigate the structure-function relationship of glaucoma progression and explore the possibility of predicting functional impairment from structural eye deterioration. We also analyze various statistical and machine-learning methods that have aided previous attempts to estimate progression, including emerging deep-learning techniques that use structural features like optical coherence tomography (OCT) scans to predict glaucoma progression accurately. We show through our investigations that these methods are still prone to confounding risk factors, especially variability due to age, data imbalances, potential noisy labels, lack of gold standard criteria, etc. We developed novel semi-supervised time-series algorithms to overcome these multifaceted challenges using unique data-driven approaches:
Weakly-Supervised Time-Series Learning: We develop a convolutional neural network-long short-term memory (CNN-LSTM) base model to encode the spatiotemporal features from the OCT scan sequence taken over a fixed follow-up. We model the rest of the deep learning architecture on the fact that original OCT sequences exhibit age-related progression, and reshuffling the sequence order, along with the knowledge of healthy eyes from a positive-unlabeled dataset, can establish robust pseudo-progression criteria for glaucoma. This circumvents the need for gold standard labels for disease progression.
Semi-supervised Time-Series Learning: We extend the above notion to a labeled case where labels are obtained from Guided Progression Analysis (GPA), a well-known, stable, and accurate functional assessment for glaucoma progression, but might be prone to noisy labels due to nuances in data acquisition. We model the age-related structural progression as a pseudo-identifier for glaucoma progression. We use this knowledge in a contrastive learning scheme where the foundational CNN-LSTM base learns accurate spatiotemporal characteristics from potentially mislabeled data and improves predictions.
Finally, we compare and show that these methods outperform conventional and state-of-the-art techniques.
Item Open Access Gaps in receipt of regular eye examinations among medicare beneficiaries diagnosed with diabetes or chronic eye diseases.(Ophthalmology, 2014-12) Sloan, Frank A; Yashkin, Arseniy P; Chen, YiqunOBJECTIVE: To examine a wide range of factors associated with regular eye examination receipt among elderly individuals diagnosed with glaucoma, age-related macular degeneration, or diabetes mellitus (DM). DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of Medicare claims linked to survey data from the Health and Retirement Study (HRS). PARTICIPANTS: The sample consisted of 2151 Medicare beneficiaries who responded to the HRS. METHODS: Medicare beneficiaries with ≥ 1 of the 3 study diagnoses were identified by diagnosis codes and merged with survey information. The same individuals were followed for 5 years divided into four 15-month periods. Predictors of the number of periods with an eye examination evaluated were beneficiary demographic characteristics, income, health, cognitive and physical function, health behaviors, subjective beliefs about longevity, the length of the individual's financial planning horizon, supplemental health insurance coverage, eye disease diagnoses, and low vision/blindness at baseline. We performed logit analysis of the number of 15-month periods in which beneficiaries received an eye examination. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome measure was the number of 15-month periods with an eye examination. RESULTS: One third of beneficiaries with the study's chronic diseases saw an eye care provider in all 4 follow-up periods despite having Medicare. One quarter only obtained an eye examination at most during 1 of the four 15-month follow-up periods. Among the 3 groups of patients studied, utilization was particularly low for persons with diagnosed DM and no eye complications. Age, marriage, education, and a higher score on the Charlson index were associated with more periods with an eye examination. Male gender, being limited in instrumental activities of daily living at baseline, distance to the nearest ophthalmologist, and low cognitive function were associated with a reduction in frequency of eye examinations. CONCLUSIONS: Rates of eye examinations for elderly persons with DM or frequently occurring eye diseases, especially for DM, remain far below recommended levels in a nationally representative sample of persons with health insurance coverage. Several factors, including limited physical and cognitive function and greater distance to an ophthalmologist, but not health insurance coverage, account for variation in regular use.Item Open Access Health literacy and glaucoma.(Current opinion in ophthalmology, 2013-03) Muir, Kelly W; Christensen, Logan; Bosworth, Hayden BPurpose of review
This review discusses the concept and measurement of health literacy, with a focus on the care of patients with glaucoma.Recent findings
Nearly one-fourth of adults in the USA lack the skills needed to fully comprehend and act on verbal or written information in the healthcare environment. This problem, referred to as poor health literacy, is associated with worse health-related outcomes in many chronic diseases, including glaucoma. Patients with glaucoma and poor literacy skills are less likely to refill their prescribed medications and miss more scheduled appointments than their more literate peers. Moreover, ophthalmic educational materials are often written at a level of readability that surpasses the skills of many patients with glaucoma.Summary
Patients with chronic eye diseases such as glaucoma and limited health literacy skills are vulnerable to poor visual outcomes. Attention to health literacy may improve the care and outcomes of these patients.Item Open Access Health Literacy and Success with Glaucoma Drop Administration.(Ophthalmology. Glaucoma, 2022-01) Kang, J Minjy; Chatterjee, Ayan; Rosdahl, Jullia A; Bosworth, Hayden B; Woolson, Sandra; Olsen, Maren; Sexton, Malina; Kirshner, Miriam; Muir, Kelly WPurpose
To assess the relationship between health literacy and successful glaucoma drop administration.Design
Substudy of a single-site interventional randomized controlled trial.Participants
Veterans receiving care at the Durham Veterans Affairs Eye Clinic who had a diagnosis of open-angle glaucoma were recruited if they endorsed poor drop adherence.Methods
Participants underwent a health literacy evaluation using the Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine (REALM) as well as a qualitative assessment of eye drop administration technique using 3 different criteria: (1) the drop was instilled in the eye, (2) only 1 drop was dispensed, and (3) the bottle was not potentially contaminated. A multivariate logistic regression model was used to assess the association of REALM score and successful drop administration, adjusting for age, disease severity, and Veterans Administration Care Assessment Needs (CAN) score.Main outcome measures
Successful drop administration.Results
Of the 179 participants with REALM scores and observed drop administration, 78% read at a high school level (HSL) or more and 22% read at less than HSL. Of the 179 participants, 87% (n = 156) successfully instilled the drop into the eye (criterion 1). A greater proportion of participants who read at HSL or more successfully instilled the drop in the eye compared with those reading at less than HSL (90.6% vs. 75.0%; P = 0.02). Rates of success with criterion 1 were similar across different levels of visual field severity. Care Assessment Needs scores were not statistically significant between those who did and those did not have successful overall drop technique.Conclusions
Poor health literacy may be associated with decreased successful drop instillation in the eye in patients with glaucoma. Screening for and considering health literacy in developing interventions to improve glaucoma self-management may improve treatment adherence in a vulnerable population.Item Open Access How Medication Adherence Affects Disease Management in Veterans with Glaucoma: Lessons Learned from a Clinical Trial.(Ophthalmic research, 2023-01) Buehne, Kristen L; Rosdahl, Jullia A; Hein, Aaron M; Woolson, Sandra; Olsen, Maren; Kirshner, Miriam; Sexton, Malina; Bosworth, Hayden B; Muir, Kelly WIntroduction
We conducted a secondary, real-world clinical assessment of a randomized controlled trial to determine how a glaucoma medication adherence intervention impacted the clinical outcomes of participants at 12 months post-randomization. Participants included veterans at a VA eye clinic with medically treated glaucoma who reported poor adherence and their companions, if applicable.Methods
The treatment group received a glaucoma education session with drop administration instruction and virtual reminders from a "smart bottle" (AdhereTech) for their eye drops. The control group received a general eye health class and the smart bottle with the reminder function turned off. Medical chart extraction determined if participants in each group experienced visual field progression, additional glaucoma medications, or a recommendation for surgery or laser due to inadequate intraocular pressure control over the 12 months following randomization. The main outcome measure was disease progression, defined as visual field progression or escalation of glaucoma therapy, in the 12 months following randomization.Results
Thirty-six versus 32% of the intervention (n = 100) versus control (n = 100) groups, respectively, experienced disease intensification. There was no difference between the intervention and control groups in terms of intensification (intervention vs. control group odds ratio: 1.20; 95% confidence interval: [0.67, 2.15]), including when age, race, and disease severity were accounted for in the logistic regression model. Those whose study dates included time during the COVID-19 pandemic were evenly distributed between groups.Conclusions
A multifaceted intervention that improved medication adherence for glaucoma for 6 months did not affect the clinical outcomes measured at 12 months post-randomization. Twelve months may not be long enough to see the clinical effect of this intervention or more than 6 months of intervention are needed.Item Open Access Improved Glaucoma Medication Adherence in a Randomized Controlled Trial.(Ophthalmology. Glaucoma, 2022-01) Muir, Kelly W; Rosdahl, Jullia A; Hein, Aaron M; Woolson, Sandra; Olsen, Maren K; Kirshner, Miriam; Sexton, Malina; Bosworth, Hayden BPurpose
To test the effectiveness of an intervention designed to improve glaucoma medication adherence.Design
Randomized, controlled trial at a Veterans Affairs (VA) eye clinic.Participants
Veterans with medically treated glaucoma who reported poor adherence and their companions if applicable.Methods
Participants, and their companions if applicable, were randomized to receive an intervention to improve medication adherence that included glaucoma education, personalized disease management suggestions, and a reminder aid, or the control arm that received education regarding general eye health.Main outcome measures
The average proportion of prescribed glaucoma medication doses taken on schedule over the 6 months after randomization according to an electronic monitor between participants in the 2 arms.Results
The mean proportion of prescribed doses taken on schedule was higher in the intervention group compared with controls (0.85 vs. 0.62, P < 0.0001). The difference in proportions between the 2 groups did not vary in regressions models adjusted for companion status, frequency of dosing, and race. The longitudinal model indicated that the intervention group had significantly higher adherence during the first month after randomization and continued to stay higher through 6 months (month by treatment interaction, P = 0.003).Conclusions
A multifaceted intervention can help improve glaucoma medication adherence.Item Open Access Increasing Glaucoma Detection in Roatán, Honduras: The Value of Education and Intraocular Pressure Screenings(2023-04-11) Pluenneke, MollyGlaucoma is an ocular neuropathy that damages the optic nerve, leading to vision loss and blindness. Insidious in its presentation and difficult to diagnose, glaucoma is asymptomatic until irreversible harm is caused. Accounting for 12.6% of preventable blindness in Honduras, glaucoma inflicts considerable clinical, economic, and personal burdens on thousands of lives (Rosa et al., 2022). Early detection and treatment halves the risk of disease progression by lowering the intraocular pressure so that permanent harm to the optic nerve is avoided (Leskea et al., 2004). However, in Roatán, where access to ophthalmic care is lacking and awareness of the disease is scarce, many cases of glaucoma go undiagnosed or are poorly managed, leading to higher rates of irreversible and avoidable blindness (Varma et al., 2011; Delgado et al., 2019). This paper seeks to understand if a two-pronged community-based strategy, which combined an educational campaign with an intraocular pressure screening, was an effective means to increase ophthalmic care seeking behavior in Roatán, Honduras. To do this, community members were given information about glaucoma and their pressure was taken with an iCare tonometer. Those with elevated pressures were recorded and contacted about follow-up. These data were then compared to the number and identity of patients who sought out ophthalmic care during a one-week medical brigade on the island to determine if the community-based approach was effective in increasing screening and detection of glaucoma. With a 7.56% follow-up rate, the analysis determined that the implemented strategy was ineffective. This study reveals a lack of timely follow-up in Roatán, demonstrating limitations in the utilized method of screening and referral. Additional interventions should be examined to determine more successful methods to increase detection of glaucoma in Roatán.Item Open Access Micro-Viscoelastic Properties of the Human Conventional Outflow Pathway and Their Evolution in an Early Ocular-Hypertension Model.(2021) Shah, Tejank PragneshPrimary OAG (POAG) is the second leading cause of irreversible blindness in the US and its prevalence is expected to worsen in the coming years. Major pathological changes have been attributed to the Juxtacanicular Tissue (JCT) and Inner Wall (IW) of Schlemm’s Canal (SC) within the human conventional outflow pathway. Biological tissues like the JCT/IW are viscoelastic in nature with both intra-cellular and extra-cellular mechanisms by which to store and dissipate applied forces. How these events contribute towards regulation of the local mechanobiology in the dynamic reciprocitybetween cells, their extracellular matrix (ECM), and in ultimately regulating outflow resistance, is poorly understood. Furthermore, the viscoelastic properties of the human trabecular meshwork (hTM) tissue are poorly understood. As a first step to develop more insight into the role of viscoelasticity, it was our goal to determine the localized dynamic mechanical properties of different regions of the hTM as a function of dexamethasone treatment. To explore the viscoelastic properties of the different tissue regions in the hTM comprising the hTM, we applied our co-located AFM-based rheometer/CLSM method to frontal sections of hTM under control and early ocular hypertensive conditions across a broad frequency range (1 Hz-1 kHz). We specifically considered the storage and loss moduli in the ocular pulse-relevant frequency range (1-10 Hz) and their changes across regions under dex treatment for two donors.
Item Open Access Randomized controlled trial of an education-based intervention to improve medication adherence: Design considerations in the medication adherence in glaucoma to improve care study.(Clinical trials (London, England), 2021-06) Rosdahl, Jullia A; Hein, Aaron M; Bosworth, Hayden B; Woolson, Sandra; Olsen, Maren; Kirshner, Miriam; Hung, Anna; Muir, Kelly WBackground
Glaucoma treatment requires patients to follow daily, often times complex, eye drop regimens, but adherence is poor for many patients, putting them at risk for irreversible vision loss. A comprehensive approach is needed to address the challenges in the self-management of glaucoma. The purpose of this study is to improve glaucoma medication adherence in Veterans with medically treated glaucoma using an education-based intervention.Methods/design
This study is a single-site randomized controlled trial enrolling 200 Veterans and their companions, if companions are involved in their care. It has two arms: an intervention group and a control group. Participants in the intervention group receive an educational session with a non-physician interventionist and are provided with an AdhereTech smart bottle with the reminder functions activated. The control group is designed as an attention control such that they have a session on general eye health and are provided with a smart bottle but without the reminder functions activated. The primary outcome is the proportion of prescribed doses taken on schedule over 6 months following randomization according to the smart bottle. Secondary outcomes include intensification of glaucoma treatment, cost of intervention delivery, and cost-effectiveness of the intervention over 12 months.Discussion
The education-based intervention that we are testing is comprehensive in scope, to encompass a variety of barriers to adherence that glaucoma patients encounter, but personalized to address issues facing individual patients. Particular attention was given to feasibility in the real-world setting, as the high throughput of patients and lack of reimbursement for educational encounters in ophthalmology would limit implementation of a resource-intensive intervention.Item Open Access Readability of patient education materials in ophthalmology: a single-institution study and systematic review.(BMC Ophthalmol, 2016-08-03) Williams, Andrew M; Muir, Kelly W; Rosdahl, Jullia ABACKGROUND: Patient education materials should be written at a level that is understandable for patients with low health literacy. The aims of this study are (1) to review the literature on readability of ophthalmic patient education materials and (2) to evaluate and revise our institution's patient education materials about glaucoma using evidence-based guidelines on writing for patients with low health literacy. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted on the PubMed/MEDLINE database for studies that have evaluated readability level of ophthalmic patient education materials, and the reported readability scores were assessed. Additionally, we collected evidence-based guidelines for writing easy-to-read patient education materials, and these recommendations were applied to revise 12 patient education handouts on various glaucoma topics at our institution. Readability measures, including Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL), and word count were calculated for the original and revised documents. The original and revised versions of the handouts were then scored in random order by two glaucoma specialists using the Suitability Assessment of Materials (SAM) instrument, a grading scale used to evaluate suitability of health information materials for patients. Paired t test was used to analyze changes in readability measures, word count, and SAM score between original and revised handouts. Finally, five glaucoma patients were interviewed to discuss the revised materials, and patient feedback was analyzed qualitatively. RESULTS: Our literature search included 13 studies that evaluated a total of 950 educational materials. Among the mean FKGL readability scores reported in these studies, the median was 11 (representing an eleventh-grade reading level). At our institution, handouts' readability averaged a tenth-grade reading level (FKGL = 10.0 ± 1.6), but revising the handouts improved their readability to a sixth-grade reading level (FKGL = 6.4 ± 1.2) (p < 0.001). Additionally, the mean SAM score of our institution's handouts improved from 60 ± 7 % (adequate) for the original versions to 88 ± 4 % (superior) for the revised handouts (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Our systematic review of the literature reveals that ophthalmic patient education materials are consistently written at a level that is too high for many patients to understand. Our institution's experience suggests that applying guidelines on writing easy-to-understand material can improve the readability and suitability of educational materials for patients with low health literacy.Item Open Access Retinal Ganglion Cells With a Glaucoma OPTN(E50K) Mutation Exhibit Neurodegenerative Phenotypes when Derived from Three-Dimensional Retinal Organoids.(Stem cell reports, 2020-07) VanderWall, Kirstin B; Huang, Kang-Chieh; Pan, Yanling; Lavekar, Sailee S; Fligor, Clarisse M; Allsop, Anna R; Lentsch, Kelly A; Dang, Pengtao; Zhang, Chi; Tseng, Henry C; Cummins, Theodore R; Meyer, Jason SRetinal ganglion cells (RGCs) serve as the connection between the eye and the brain, with this connection disrupted in glaucoma. Numerous cellular mechanisms have been associated with glaucomatous neurodegeneration, and useful cellular models of glaucoma allow for the precise analysis of degenerative phenotypes. Human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) serve as powerful tools for studying human disease, particularly cellular mechanisms underlying neurodegeneration. Thus, efforts focused upon hPSCs with an E50K mutation in the Optineurin (OPTN) gene, a leading cause of inherited forms of glaucoma. CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing introduced the OPTN(E50K) mutation into existing lines of hPSCs, as well as generating isogenic controls from patient-derived lines. RGCs differentiated from OPTN(E50K) hPSCs exhibited numerous neurodegenerative deficits, including neurite retraction, autophagy dysfunction, apoptosis, and increased excitability. These results demonstrate the utility of OPTN(E50K) RGCs as an in vitro model of neurodegeneration, with the opportunity to develop novel therapeutic approaches for glaucoma.Item Open Access The Relationship of Trabecular Meshwork Stiffness and Outflow Function(2013) Camras, LucindaThe trabecular meshwork (TM) is comparable to a bioactive filter that plays a major role in regulating outflow of aqueous humor of the eye and setting intraocular pressure (IOP). TM dysfunction may lead to ocular hypertension which is the major risk factor in glaucoma. Although the outflow properties of the TM have been assessed over the last sixty years, very little work has been done assessing its mechanical properties. Therefore, the major goals of these studies were two-fold: (1) to determine the relationship between mechanical properties of TM, specifically the bulk Young's modulus, and outflow function in normal and glaucomatous eyes, and (2) to establish a method and possible animal model for future testing of this relationship.
Outflow function was assessed by constant pressure perfusion in enucleated eyes at four pressure levels (10, 20, 30, and 40 mmHg) to determine outflow facilities and variability in outflow resistance with pressure elevation. A micro-strain analyzer (MSA) was used to determine the circumferential bulk Young's modulus of the TM post-perfusion. Based on their relative ease of availability, pigs and rats were explored as possible animal models. Due to the small size of rat eyes, atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to assess the Young's modulus of TM rather than with a MSA.
We found that there was a relationship with better outflow function and a stiffer TM in normal eyes. Additionally, glaucomatous TM was found to be much softer and more variable than normal TM. Unfortunately, porcine TM did not serve as a good model for the bulk Young's modulus of human TM, presumably due to anatomical difference in its outflow pathway. Lastly, we were able to establish a new method for measuring the Young's modulus of rat TM for future work to determine potential mechanism for evaluating stiffness changes that may be associated with glaucoma.
Item Open Access Within-Trial Cost-Effectiveness of an Adherence-Enhancing Educational Intervention for Glaucoma.(American journal of ophthalmology, 2022-12) Williams, Andrew M; Theophanous, Christos; Muir, Kelly W; Rosdahl, Jullia A; Woolson, Sandra; Olsen, Maren; Bosworth, Hayden B; Hung, AnnaPurpose
To assess the within-trial cost-effectiveness of a behavioral intervention to improve glaucoma medication adherence.Design
Prospective cost-effectiveness analysis of randomized, controlled trial data.Methods
The study setting was a Veterans Affairs (VA) eye clinic. The patient population comprised veterans with medically treated glaucoma and self-reported poor adherence. Participants were randomized to a personalized educational session with a reminder bottle to promote medication adherence or to a control session on general eye health. Costs were assessed from the perspective of the VA payor at 6 months using the VA Managerial Cost Accounting System. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted using bootstrapped samples. The main outcome measures were the proportion of participants attaining ≥80% adherence as measured by electronic monitor, total intervention and medical resource costs, and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios comparing intervention to control at 6 months.Results
Of 200 randomized participants, 95 of 100 assigned to the intervention and 97 of 100 assigned to the control had adherence outcomes at 6 months, and the proportion of adherent patients was higher in the intervention group compared to control (0.78 vs 0.40, P < .0001). All participants had costs at 6 months. The total cost at 6 months was $1,149,600 in the intervention group (n = 100) compared to $1,298,700 in the control group (n = 100). Thus, in a hypothetical cohort of 100 patients, the intervention was associated with cost savings (-$149,100) and resulted in 38 additional patients achieving medication adherence.Conclusions
An adherence-enhancing behavioral intervention was effective and cost saving at 6 months.