Browsing by Subject "Mental health"
- Results Per Page
- Sort Options
Item Open Access A Comparative Sociological Investigation of the Conceptions and Perceptions of Mental Health and Illness in Arica, Chile and Rome, Italy(2013-05-08) Kontchou, Nelly-AngeThis comparative study aimed to discover the principal factors that influence the perceptions of citizens in Arica, Chile and Rome, Italy toward mental illness. Specifically, the study aimed to investigate how these perceptions affect the societal acceptance of mentally ill individuals and to identify potential sources of stigma. In both cities, mental health services exist for free use by citizens, but stigma makes the use of these services and the acceptance of those who use them somewhat taboo. Past studies on the topic of mental health stigma have investigated the barriers to accessing mental health services (Acuña & Bolis 2005), the inception and effects of Basaglia’s Law (Tarabochia 2011), strategies to combat stigma (López et al. 2008) and images of mental illness in the media (Stout, Villeagas & Jennings 2004). To discover Aricans’ opinions on mental health and illness, personal interviews were administered to five mental health professionals, and a 20-question survey was administered to 131 members of the general population. In Rome, 27 subjects answered an 18-question survey as well as an interview, and 12 professionals participated in narrative interviews. From these interviews and surveys, the lack of economic, structural and human resources to effectively manage mental health programs was gleaned. Moreover, many participants identified how stigma infringed upon the human rights of those with mental illnesses and opined that they were barely accepted in society. Conclusions drawn were that stigma stems from multiple concurrent sources, and strategies to reduce it must align with each society’s unique needs. Stigma prevents people from caring for their mental health and from integrating those with mental illness.Item Open Access A Descriptive Study of Emotional Well-Being Among Women in Ghana(2012) Kyerematen, VictoriaMental illness is prevalent worldwide in all cultures with varying manifestations. Its socioeconomic impact cannot be underestimated. Mental health accounts for as much as 14 percent of the global disease burden (Prince, et al. 2007) and depression is ranked as the fourth leading contributor to the global disease burden. Nevertheless, mental health remains largely ignored worldwide, especially in developing nations.
This cross-sectional study, examines depression in two rural districts in Ghana, West Africa. Ghana, like many African nations, consists of many ethnic groups, with lineage networks that dictate personal and public behaviors. Ghana is unique in that approximately half of the population belongs to the Akan, matrilineal clan. The study hypothesized that by examining two clan groups (the Akan and Ga-Adangbe) that differed in lineage a statistically significant difference in rates of depression would be ascertained.
Upon receipt of ethical board approval from the Duke University Institutional Review Board in Durham, NC and Noguchi Memorial Institute for Medical Research Institutional Review Board in Ghana, researchers using the Depression Anxiety Stress Scales Short form (DASS-21) in a geographically randomly selected sample to measure depression as well as anxiety and stress among the participants and a demographic survey, researchers compared the prevalence of depression between the matrilineal Akan clan and patrilineal Ga-Adangbe clan. Data was analyzed using STATA 11.0.
The results indicate a rejection of the null hypothesis. There is a statistically significant difference in depression score between the women in the Ga-Adangbe clan and Akan clan. This study reports high co-morbidity of anxiety and stress with depression. Further research should expand to include other tribes in Ghana and other mental illnesses.
Item Open Access A Friend in Need: The Influence of Friendship on the Psychosocial Adjustment of Youth with Chronic Health Conditions(2015) Wigdor, AlissaFriendship has consistently been found to act as a buffer against psychological maladjustment for healthy youth and youth experiencing difficulties including parental divorce and natural disasters. Less known is the role of friendship may have for females coping with a chronic health problem. Therefore, the objective of the current study was to evaluate the health factors and friendship precursors that may influence friendship, and in turn, how those friendships may predict psychosocial adjustment. A sample of chronically ill females (N = 30) was compared to a control group of healthy females (N = 45) on measures of opportunities for social interaction, similarity to their best friend, social capability, friendship quality, and psychological adjustment. Results revealed that health condition and friendship precursors were not associated with friendship quality. However, higher friendship quality was predictive of fewer externalizing symptoms for healthy girls. Additionally, positive parent relationships predicted fewer internalizing symptoms for both groups of females. Notably, chronically ill girls noted their friendships were higher in punishment and lower in companionship than healthy girls. Further assessment, including objective measures, will elucidate the beneficial processes of friendships and parent-child relationships that buffer youth from maladjustment.
Item Open Access A mixed-methods study to validate a measure of and explore influences on child mental health in Eldoret, Kenya(2017) Haynes, Taylor MargaretBackground: In Kenya, approximately 14.5% of children and youth meet criteria for a mental disorder. Despite this high burden, research is very limited related to mental health problems this population. Research is needed on the measurement of child mental health problems and on the risk and protective factors associated with these conditions.
Objectives: (1) Evaluate a set of survey items, chosen from both standardized measures and locally developed items, to identify those that that best differentiate between children with and without mental health problems. (2) Identify and explore important individual- and family-level influences on child mental health.
Methods: Individual surveys and semi-structured interviews were administered to members (1-2 caregivers, 1 child age 8-17) of 22 families living in Eldoret, Kenya. We evaluated differences in survey item endorsement between children with and without mental health problems to identify the best performing items. We used mixed-methods analysis of semi-structured interview transcripts and associated rating scores to explore differences between children with and without mental health problems on a variety of family-level variables.
Results: Following an extensive cultural adaptation process, fourteen of 26 survey items were successful in differentiating between children with and without mental health problems. Successful survey items were all drawn from standardized measures; no locally developed items were successful. All family-level variables (e.g., overall family functioning, couples’ relationship quality, parent-child relationship quality, and caregiver mental health) were strongly associated with child mental health outcomes, evidenced by large effect sizes ranging from 0.86 to 4.16. Subsequent qualitative analysis identified specific components of these variables likely contributing to the large numerical differences in scores.
Conclusions: The results of this study both suggest that standardized measures are appropriate for use in this population and highlight the importance of cultural adaptation before implementing standardized assessment tools. Additionally, the results indicate that the family environment is a promising target for interventions aiming to reduce mental health problems in Kenyan children.
Item Open Access A Multi-Stakeholder Perspective on Factors Affecting Successful Transition to Adulthood for Youth with Severe Emotional Disturbances.(Child & adolescent social work journal : C & A, 2022-11) Cox, Milira; Urban, Jennifer Brown; Lich, Kristen Hassmiller; Wells, Rebecca; Lawrence, C Nicole; Kwaja, NadiraThis study elicited the perspectives of youth, caregivers, service providers and researchers to explore how communities can best support the transition to adulthood for youth ages 16-21 with mental health and functional impairments, who are at risk of disconnecting from health and human services. Framed by Relational Systems Evaluation (RSE) and Positive Youth Development (PYD), our study demonstrates the importance of engagement with youth experts. Group Concept Mapping (GCM), a collaborative multiphase mixed-methods approach, was used as a systematic process for participants to make meaning of qualitative data using multidimensional scaling and hierarchical cluster analysis (Kane and Trochim in Concept mapping for planning and evaluation, Sage Publications Inc., Thousand Oaks, 2007). Across all participant groups, Life Skills were perceived as highly important and highly feasible for a successful transition to adulthood. However, Positive Social Support & Connectedness were viewed as less important and less feasible by all groups. When examined closely, youth perspectives differed from caregiver and provider perspectives in the factors they prioritized and deemed feasible. Our findings have implications for community mental health services and positive youth development program practitioners.Item Open Access A Nationally Representative Survey of Depression Symptoms among Jordanian Adolescents: Associations with Depression Stigma, Depression Etiological Beliefs, and Likelihood to Seek Help for Depression(2017) Dardas, Latefa AliProblem and Purpose: Arab adolescents are considered a particularly vulnerable population to depression. The substantial lack of mental health services and the stigma associated with mental illness on the one hand; and poverty, unemployment, and lack of reasonable hopes for a decent future in the context of corruption of regimes and perceived social injustice on the other, call for establishing committed and effective policies to tackle depression and its associated stigma among Arab adolescents at risk for or diagnosed with depression. However, there is a substantial lack of research that can inform the current profile of adolescent depression in the Arab region. We conducted two systematic reviews on Adolescent depression and mental illness stigma in the Arab region and found that there is currently no solid evidence available on the prevalence of depression among Arab adolescents and its potential associations with depression stigma and help-seeking beliefs and intentions. This gap in the literature makes it difficult to design, implement, and disseminate effective interventions to improve the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of adolescent depression. Therefore, the overarching purpose of this study was to estimate a prevalence of depression symptoms among Arab adolescents, and determine relationships with depression stigma, depression etiologic beliefs, and likelihood to seek help for depression.
Methods: This study was conducted in Jordan, a Middle Eastern Arab country. A pilot study with a sample of 88 Jordanian adolescents was first conducted to assess the feasibility of collaboration and coordination with the proposed recruitment sites; assess proposed recruitment strategies; confirm the utility of the translated self-reported measures and examining their psychometric properties; and obtaining preliminary findings. Based on the lessons learned from this pilot study, we designed a nationally representative, school-based survey. Data were collected from 2,349 adolescents aged 12-17, using a packet of self-administered questionnaires that included measures on sociodemographic and health history, depression severity, depression stigma, depression etiologic beliefs, and likelihood to seek help for depression. A passive consenting procedure was used to obtain parental consents, while returning the survey questionnaires was considered a tacit assent for the adolescents. The study obtained the needed Institutional Review Board approvals from both Duke University and the University of Jordan. Participants represented all three regions in the country, with 34% from the northern (suburban) region, 43% from the central (urban) region, and 23% from the southern (rural) region.
Results: The majority of the adolescents were females (59%) and 15-17 years old (67%). Almost 14% reported having at least one chronic health problem, 15% reported having a mental health problem, 25% reported having academic difficulties, 8% reported that they had received a psychiatric diagnosis, and 22% reported that they had sought psychological help at some point in the past. The mean total depression score was 16.3 (SD=11.2, 95% CI=15.8 to 16.7), with 34% of the sample reporting moderate to severe depression. Depression was significantly higher among respondents who were female, ages 14-15 years, and living in families with monthly incomes less than JD300 (USD 423); and who reported having a chronic health problem, mental health problem, learning difficulty, a psychiatric diagnosis and/or seeking previous psychological help. Adolescents endorsed multiple etiological factors for depression. The most often reported factors were stressful events in one’s life (72%), social factors (65%), and one’s weak will (56%). On the other hand, the least reported factors were genetic or inherited problems (24%), chemical imbalance (30%), and punishment for wrong doings (35%). Adolescents were more likely to seek help for depression from a family member (57%), followed by a counselor (46%), psychiatrist (43%), religious leader (39%), and general practitioner (28%). In addition, 53% of the adolescents reported they will be willing to take medications for depression, while 50% expressed willingness to seek a therapy, and 25% of the adolescents reported they will not be willing to seek any professional help for depression. Almost half of the adolescents agreed on items that reflect stigmatizing attitudes towards depression. Adolescents reported higher rates of perceived depression stigma than personal depression stigma. Depression stigma was not significantly associated with the adolescent’s severity of depression, but with adolescent’s sex, age, region of residence, parents’ education, and history of mental health problem.
Conclusions: This study revealed alarming results in terms of the current high prevalence and social determinants of adolescent depression in Jordan. The study also shed light on how depression stigma manifests among Jordanian adolescents and how such stigma relates to their beliefs about depression and likelihood to seek professional psychological help. We discuss how healthcare providers, researchers, and educators can focus attention on developing effective and culturally appropriate screening, prevention, and intervention approaches using evidence-based guidelines to promote Jordanian adolescent mental health, particularly for depression. This approach will be important not only for Jordan, but for all of the Arab region, given that many of the Arab countries have been witnessing years of mass violence, armed conflicts, and war. The study also provides important recommendations on when, how, and why to utilize school settings for anti-depression stigma interventions. Overall, findings from this study provide a solid, culturally competent foundation from which to conduct future research to tackle depression and its associated stigma, and reflect the unique characteristics of Arab culture.
Item Open Access Aging in South Asia: Attitudes/Beliefs of Elders in Southern India and Long-Term Care of the Elderly in Southern Sri Lanka(2013) Beaudry, Lauren JeanetteDeveloping nations in Asia are posed to experience a significant increase in the population of older adults living in their respective societies. Over the coming decades, India, the second most populous country in the entire world, is poised to experience a significant increase in its elder population. India's population of adults 60 years of age or older is projected to increase from 8% to 19% of the countries total population by the year 2050. Figures predict that by mid-century, 323 million people in India will be aged 60 years or older, more than the total current U.S. population. As the demographic structure of India is making a dramatic shift, concerns regarding the health and wellbeing of the growing Indian elder population are emerging, as is the growing concern for social policy. In addition, Sri Lanka is the fastest aging nation in South Asia. Multiple factors, including an increase in the number of people considered to be the "oldest old" (80+ years of age), a decrease in the number of working age adults, and increases in disability amongst the elderly, could necessitate an increased need for institutionalization of elderly Sri Lankans into long-term care facilities.
This project aims to study aging in south Asia from two different perspectives. An analysis of existing data from Southern India was done to examine the attitudes and beliefs of Indian elders towards aging and support systems for the elderly. Mental health of Indian elders was assessed and logistic regression analysis was conducted to examine possible correlations between attitudes and beliefs of the elderly and elder mental health. In addition, a qualitative descriptive study of Sri Lankan elder homes was carried out in the southern district of Galle, Sri Lanka. A convenience sampling method was used to identify six elder homes located in the area, and visits were made to each of the homes. During the visits, elder home mangers were interviewed in order to gain general information on the functioning and history of the elder homes, as well as general information on the residents living at the facilities.
Results from the Kerala Aging Survey revealed that psychological distress was present for over one third of elders in Kerala. Rates of psychological distress were higher for women, the poor, and those with advanced age. Elder women appear to be especially vulnerable to psychological distress in old age. Elders believe that children are responsible for supporting parents in their old age; lack of satisfaction with support received from children was associated with the presence of psychological distress amongst elders. For the qualitative study on Sri Lankan elders homes, it was found that both familial and community support are significant factors in the long-term care of elderly Sri Lankans. Though many elder home residents had been diagnosed with a chronic NCD or disability, lack of familial support was consistently identified as the driving force necessitating the elderly to reside at the long-term care facilities. With little or no financial assistance from the government, the facilities themselves all relied heavily on donations from the community to function on a daily basis.
Item Open Access Association of Black Race With Physical and Chemical Restraint Use Among Patients Undergoing Emergency Psychiatric Evaluation(2022) Smith, Colin MichaelObjective: Few studies have examined the disproportionate use of restraints for Black adults receiving emergency psychiatric care. This study sought to determine whether the odds of physical and chemical restraint use were higher for Black patients undergoing emergency psychiatric care compared with their white counterparts.
Methods: This single-center retrospective cohort study examined 12,977 unique encounters of adults receiving an emergency psychiatric evaluation between January 1, 2014, and September 18, 2020, at a large academic medical center in Durham, North Carolina. Self-reported race categories were extracted from the electronic medical record. Primary outcomes were the presence of a behavioral physical restraint order or chemical restraint administration during the emergency department encounter. Covariates included age, sex, ethnicity, height, time of arrival, positive urine drug screen results, peak blood-alcohol concentration, and diagnosis of a bipolar or psychotic disorder.
Results: A total of 961 (7.4%) encounters involved physical restraint, and 2,047 (15.8%) involved chemical restraint. Models with and without a race covariate were compared by using quasi-likelihood information criterion (QIC) scores; in each instance, the model with race performed better than the model without. Black patients were more likely to be physically (adjusted odds ratio [AOR]=1.35; 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.07–1.72) and chemically (AOR=1.33; 95% CI=1.15–1.55) restrained than white patients.
Conclusions: After adjusting for measured confounders, Black patients undergoing psychiatric evaluation were at higher odds of experiencing physical or chemical restraint compared with white patients, which is consistent with the growing body of evidence revealing racial inequities in psychiatric care.
Item Open Access Associations between Self-Stigma and Emotional Wellbeing Among Orphans(2022) Wilkerson, MadelineResearchers have been searching for ways to improve outcomes for orphaned and separated children (OSC) worldwide. OSC have a particularly high rate of mental health disorders and lower emotional wellbeing. Stigma has been shown to be a predictor of mental health disorders and emotional wellbeing for HIV and children in poverty. However, no research has been conducted with OSC examining the relationship between self-stigma and emotional wellbeing. Using Round 10 of the Positive Outcomes for Orphans (POFO) study with 2013 orphans from Kenya, Ethiopia, Tanzania, India, and Cambodia, a linear model was implemented to examine the association between self-stigma and emotional wellbeing. Through the building of a linear regression model, self-stigma was shown to be a strong predictor of emotional wellbeing as measured by the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ). This indicates that self-stigma may be a significant factor to address when looking at ways to improve emotional wellbeing among orphans.
Item Open Access Associations of Adverse Childhood Experiences With Key Health Outcomes and Viral Suppression Maintenance Among Tanzanian Youth Living With HIV(2022) Brtek, Veronica RaquelBackground: Despite improved access to HIV testing and medication, AIDS remains a leading cause of death among youth living with HIV (YLWH) in Tanzania. YLWH are prone to worse HIV outcomes than other age groups, which may be caused or mediated by mental health, social determinants of health (SDH), and adverse childhood experiences (ACEs). In this study, the investigators sought to determine if ACEs were correlated with key health variables in hopes of better understanding the factors associated with negative HIV and mental health outcomes among Tanzanian youth. Additionally, the investigators aimed to observe longitudinal trends in virologic suppression to understand the extent to which undetectable = untransmittable or “U=U” messaging applies to the more volatile youth demographic. Finally, the investigators sought to identify patterns and predictors that could aid in understanding risk of virologic failure in this population. Methods: The investigators incorporated and merged secondary data from participants who were enrolled in both of two distinct studies to create a longitudinal database spanning from 2013 to 2020. Participant ACE scores were derived from trauma exposure questionnaires and were compared with data about mental health, stigma, SDH, sexual experiences, self-reported adherence and HIV RNA (viral load). Associations of ACEs and other key variables were performed using linear regression. Results: ACEs were common among YLWH, especially loss of a parent and physical abuse. ACEs were also correlated with both mental health outcomes and virologic failure. Of the 48 participants who were virologically suppressed at the beginning of the study, one third had subsequent virologic failure, which was often associated with changes in ACEs, medication regimen, and SDH. Conclusion: Understanding common ACEs in this vulnerable population has direct relevance for the design of targeted interventions to prevent and treat repercussions of childhood trauma and improve mental health and HIV outcomes. ACEs, experiences with suicide risk, and low social support are important correlates of virologic failure and should be an alert when considering repeat HIV RNA testing and eligibility for supportive services.
Item Open Access Behavioral Health Service Utilization and Cost for North Carolina’s Foster Children: A Report for Partnering For Excellence(2014-04-18) Foosness, SusanExecutive Summary Introduction The foster care population in North Carolina, which hovered around 8,882 children as of August 2013, is of special interest to policymakers, politicians, Medicaid officials, child welfare professionals, and healthcare providers. This group of infants through young adults faces unique challenges in their educational, social, emotional, developmental, and physical growth. Their elevated needs put extra pressure on already stressed systems with limited financial resources. High levels of behavioral health and emotional problems lead to placement disruptions, costly interventions, and require extra diligence on the part of caseworkers, foster parents, and professionals to manage crises and keep foster children safe. It is essential to identify strategies to address the behavioral health needs of foster children within the constraints of limited resources, and in ways that take advantage of the most recent research on evidence-based treatments. These strategies should aim to reduce placement disruptions and promote healthy outcomes for foster children. By using existing data collection systems within the Department of Social Services and Local Management Entity-Managed Care Organizations (LME-MCOs), we can gain important insight into this population’s health and mental health needs, access to services, utilization, and cost. These data will also provide us with an opportunity to improve the existing systems and recommend policy changes. Policy Question How can county Departments of Social Services (DSS) and Local Management Entity-Managed Care Organizations (LME-MCOs) use existing data to better manage the foster care population and improve mental health outcomes? Policy Recommendations 1. Stakeholders should focus on increasing the frequency and quality of trauma-informed comprehensive clinical assessments for children in contact with child welfare. 2. Cardinal Innovations and behavioral health providers should continue to expand the service array of Evidence Based Practices available in Rowan County. 3. Cardinal Innovations should expand their use of care coordination to all children in DSS custody. 4. Cardinal Innovations and Rowan County DSS should identify high-cost and high utilization indicators in cases and target them with wraparound services like care coordination and additional case management at DSS. 5. DSS should implement data collection systems to monitor and track every placement change for children in DSS custody and note the specific reason. 6. DSS and Cardinal Innovations should encourage continuity of care with behavioral health providers and insist that barriers to treatment or placement stability be addressed. 7. DSS workers should be trained to recognize the different types of evidence-based therapies available and how to access them in their community. Methodology The data required for this project was obtained by Dr. Rosanbalm and the Partnering for Excellence pilot through Benchmarks and de-identified for analysis. The data come from four major databases from the State Data Warehouse and Cardinal Innovations Healthcare Solutions. These data include Child Protective Services (CPS) Data, Service Information System (SIS) Data, Child Placement and Payment System (CPPS) Data, and Medicaid Behavioral Health Services Data. The analysis conducted was intended to be exploratory, not causal, in nature. The goal was to obtain a thorough understanding of the baseline relationships between child welfare and behavioral health services in Rowan County. Without a counterfactual group or quasi-experimental design, it was not possible to make causal inferences about the effect of behavioral health services on the child welfare population. After the available data was analyzed, a reported was created based on initial interpretations and shared with Benchmarks, Cardinal, and county DSS stakeholders for further analysis and to guide final recommendations. The recommendations are informed by the existing literature from academia, child welfare practice, evidence-based treatments, and advocacy and policy groups. The data analysis from Rowan County has led to specific recommendations to improve county practices and policies, inform the Partnering for Excellence pilot, and suggest recommendations that could be implemented statewide in North Carolina. Discussion Children in foster care, by definition, have experienced trauma including the removal from their family and entry into foster care, and have likely experienced child abuse or neglect. We know from the research and experience that these foster children have increased mental health issues and psychiatric diagnoses. There may be barriers that delay or prevent foster children from receiving timely, comprehensive, and useful mental health assessments and further delays in entering evidence-based treatment to address their mental health issues. The data analysis in this paper confirms what the literature on foster children across the United States has found: foster children have significantly greater behavioral health issues, utilize more services, and account for a disproportionate amount of behavioral health expenditures. The analysis presented in this paper highlights a concern that there may be inadequate and inconsistent behavioral health assessments of high-risk children who have contact with CPS, and particularly for children in DSS custody. There may be practical barriers or case coordination issues that are preventing timely and comprehensive clinical assessments of these children. For example, the decreased rates of assessment among Hispanic children may indicate linguistic, cultural, or insurance barriers for undocumented children. Prior to the development of Partnering for Excellence the workforce in Rowan County was unable to accommodate the need for trauma-informed comprehensive clinical assessments. This may explain the use of developmentally inappropriate diagnostic labels or treatment services in the data. For example, it’s concerning that twelve 6 to 11 year old children received substance abuse treatment services. While these children may have been experimenting with substances, substance abuse treatment models are developmentally inappropriate for young children and their issues may have been better addressed by behavioral health services. Additionally, diagnosis of personality disorders in children under 18 years old, MST with children under 12 (as was the case with 10 children), and bipolar diagnoses in young children are all concerning practices that may stem from a lack of experience or resources in the community. It is well established in the literature and anecdotally that foster children’s undiagnosed and untreated mental health issues can lead to challenging externalizing behaviors (tantrums, aggression, lying, etc.) that strain their relationships with their foster parents and can lead to placement disruption. Foster care placements also frequently disrupt for administrative or policy reasons. Either way, the effect and feelings of rejection and instability are the same for the foster child. Research has shown that placement disruptions, particularly in the first 100 days of care, exacerbate foster children’s mental health issues and are associated with more frequent placement changes in the future. Placement disruption may also be associated with increased reliance on the Medicaid-funded residential treatment placements. Placement disruptions and entry into the residential treatment pipeline can delay reunification, prevent adoption or guardianship, and may be correlated with re-entry into foster care. DSS placement disruptions create administrative costs for the Department, disrupt behavioral health service delivery, and can lead to expensive reliance on residential treatment. This entire chain of negative events fails to capture the real and intangible costs to the child’s education and physical and emotional well-being, nor the increased costs associated with administrative procedures, school changes, court procedures, and informal case management. The analysis presented in this paper highlights the concerns about placement stability for children in DSS custody. Children with short first placements (less than 100 days) and more than one placement go on to have more placements overall and these placements are short, indicating that these children are “bouncing around” through placements. Placement instability is also associated with increased average behavioral health expenditures. It follows then, that these children have likely received multiple psychiatric diagnoses and are receiving a wide spectrum of behavioral health services with limited success. Finally, this paper emphasizes the value in utilizing wraparound services such as care coordination by the LME-MCO or Multisystemic Therapy (MST) prior to or following more expensive and intensive residential treatment options. Care coordination can improve the communication between providers, help ensure continuity of care during placement changes, and delay or prevent hospitalizations and other crises. MST has demonstrated effectiveness in preventing out-of-home placements and can effectively address conduct disorder behaviors that can lead to placement disruption and later reliance on institutional care or criminal behavior. For further information regarding this report please contact the author, Susan Cohen Foosness, MSW at sdc28@duke.edu.Item Open Access Branded: How Mental Disorder Labels Alter Task Performance in Perception and Reality(2013) Foy, Steven LarrimoreExtensive evidence demonstrates how mental illness symptomatology can inhibit perceptions of and actual performance on important tasks. However, receiving treatment from the medical establishment for such symptomatology requires diagnosis, whereby the patient becomes labeled and subject to the stereotypes connected to that label. Mental illness labeling is associated with a variety of negative outcomes including inhibited access to unemployment, housing, health insurance, and marriage and parenthood opportunities and can disrupt interpersonal relationships. However, the repercussions of mental illness labeling for one area of life have remained largely overlooked; that area is task performance. Adults spend a substantial portion of their lives at work engaged in group-based or individual level tasks. This dissertation explores external perceptions of mental illness in task groups and the role of self-internalization of stereotypes about mental illness in individual task performance through two experimental studies.
Previous research has revealed that, on average, task partners with a mental illness are stigmatized and subject to diminished status when they are identified to participants as having been hospitalized for general psychological problems for an extended period of time. Study 1 of this dissertation explores the stigma- and status-based attributions triggered by engaging with a partner in a mutual task who is identified as having a specific mental illness label: none, Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD), Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), or schizophrenia.
Additionally, research has revealed that members of a group about which negative stereotypes exist may face a situational threat in a domain relevant task--stereotype threat. Race, gender, social class, age, and a variety of other sociodemographic attributes can trigger stereotype threat. However, little research has considered the potential for stereotype threat to emerge on the basis of mental illness labeling. Study 2 of this dissertation focusing on individual-level performance, exploring the potential for ADHD to trigger stereotype threat in test-taking situations.
Results from Study 1 suggest that the specific mental illness labels studied, presented devoid of symptomatology severity, do not trigger stigmatized attributions but may trigger some negative status attributions in the case of a task relevant diagnosis. (ADHD). Study 2 suggests that a task relevant diagnosis may also trigger stereotype threat in a test-taking situation, negatively impacting performance. Taken together, the results indicate that task relevance of one's mental illness label may be a driving factor in negative external and internal perceptions of mental illness.
Item Open Access Building a Decision Model to Estimate the Health and Economic Benefits of Targeted Mental Health Interventions to Improve ART Adherence among Young People Living with HIV in Tanzania(2023) Fawole, Ayodamope OlaoluwaYoung people living with HIV (YPLWH) constitute a growing proportion of the global population of people living with HIV but have less access to HIV testing, diagnosis, treatment, and face heightened mental health challenges. To address these challenges, targeted mental health and medication adherence interventions have been developed, including in Tanzania, which is home to 6% of the world's YPLWH. This study proposes a mathematical model to estimate the health and economic outcomes of mental health HIV adherence interventions targeting YPLWH in Tanzania.We developed a Markov model to predict the long-term health (Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALY)) and economic outcomes (Value of a Statistical Life Year (VLSY)) of mental health HIV adherence interventions targeting YPLWH. We parameterized the model using outcomes data from the 2016-2020 Sauti ya Vijana randomized control trial (RCT) conducted in Moshi, Tanzania. Cost data were retrieved from a cost analysis of the same RCT and supplemented with data from published literature. The study is conducted from a health payer’s perspective, and the Willingness-To-Pay (WTP) per DALY averted was set to the 2021 Tanzanian GDP per capita (USD 1099.3). Costs and outcomes were modeled for ten years and discounted at an annual rate of 3%. The findings suggest that the Sauti ya Vijana intervention modeled in this study is cost-effective at a WTP of USD 1099.3. The Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for the intervention compared to the standard of care was USD 637.06 per DALY averted at a 3% discount rate. The benefit-to-cost ratio of the intervention was USD 26.54 in economic productivity for the intervention arm for every dollar spent on the intervention, and the net economic productivity benefit was USD 17,174.74 over a decade. Mental health adherence interventions hold the promise of improving health outcomes amongst YPLWH. The mathematical model developed in this study is a valuable decision-making tool for policymakers regarding mental health adherence interventions targeting YPLWH in Tanzania. The model contributes to the global goal of achieving the UNAIDS 95-95-95 targets for YPLWH.
Item Open Access Caring and thriving: An international qualitative study of caregivers of orphaned and vulnerable children and strategies to sustain positive mental health(Children and Youth Services Review, 2019-03-01) Proeschold-Bell, RJ; Molokwu, NJ; Keyes, CLM; Sohail, MM; Eagle, DE; Parnell, HE; Kinghorn, WA; Amanya, C; Vann, V; Madan, I; Biru, BM; Lewis, D; Dubie, ME; Whetten, K© 2018 Background: Child well-being is associated with caregiver mental health. Research has focused on the absence or presence of mental health problems, such as depression, in caregivers. However, positive mental health – defined as the presence of positive emotions, psychological functioning, and social functioning – likely prevents depression and in caregivers may benefit children more than the mere absence of mental health problems. Little attention has been given to how caregivers sustain positive mental health, particularly when doing challenging work in impoverished settings. Objective: The study's objective was to determine what successful caregivers of orphaned and vulnerable children (OVC) in diverse countries do to sustain their positive mental health. Methods: Using a mixed-methods, cross-sectional study design, trained local interviewers recruited a convenience sample of OVC caregivers through residential care institutions from five geographic regions (Kenya; Ethiopia; Cambodia; Hyderabad, India; and Nagaland, India). Participants completed surveys and in-depth interviews about strategies used to sustain their mental health over time or improve it during challenging times. Results: Sixty-nine OVC caregivers from 28 residential care institutions participated. Positive mental health survey scores were high. We organized the strategies named into six categories ordered from most to least frequently named: Religious Practices; Engaging in Caregiving; Social Support; Pleasurable Activities; Emotion Regulation; and Removing Oneself from Work. Prayer and reading religious texts arose as common strategies. Participants reported promoting positive emotions by focusing on their work's meaning and playing with children. The similar findings across diverse regions were striking. Some differences included more emphasis on emotion control in Ethiopia; listening to music/singing in Kenya and Hyderabad; and involving children in the tasks the participants enjoyed less (e.g., cleaning) in Cambodia. Conclusions: Under real-world conditions, small daily activities appeared to help sustain positive mental health. In addition, fostering structures that allow caregivers to engage regularly in rewarding caregiving tasks may be an affordable and scalable idea which could potentially benefit caregivers, children, and employers.Item Open Access Childhood Adversities and Adult Mental Health: Conceptualizing and Measuring Heterogeneity in Adversity Experience(2022) Kamis, ChristinaThe life course perspective has long theorized that childhood is a sensitive period for mental, physical, and emotional development, meaning that negative experiences during childhood can have long-lasting impacts on health and wellbeing. Thus, adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), such as parental alcoholism, sexual abuse, and physical neglect, during this sensitive period of the life course may elicit poor mental health both in childhood and as children age into adulthood. Although research on the long term impact of childhood adversity is growing, this research has been somewhat limited in the measurement of childhood adversity, focusing on dichotomous measures (occurred/ did not occur) or the summation of such dichotomous measures. In doing so, this research fails to capture heterogeneity in adversity experience, such as the severity, duration, and context of childhood adversities as well as how specific types of adversities may co-occur, consequently underestimating the impact of negative experiences for those at greatest risk of poor mental health. In this dissertation, I explore how these sources of distinction pattern mental health trajectories, with consequences for mental health disparities across the life course. In broadening the definition of childhood adversity beyond the simple occurrence of negative events, this dissertation provides an analytic blueprint for future research assessing childhood adversity, contributing to stress, life course, and mental health studies. In Chapter 2, I focus on a single adverse experience, parental mental health problems in childhood, to showcase how differences in severity, duration, and context of an adversity correspond to different mental health patterns across adulthood. Using six waves of data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID; 2007-2017) and applying growth curve methods I find that more severe and longer exposures to parental mental health problems in childhood correspond to even greater distress in adulthood. The gender of the parent afflicted does not predict differences in adult mental health, but those individuals exposed to both maternal and paternal poor mental health in childhood have the greatest distress in adulthood. Chapters 3 and 4 focus on two other sources of heterogeneity in childhood adversity experience: the number and type of childhood adverse events. These chapters employ latent class analysis (LCA) to capture latent subtypes who are similar in their responses to a set of indicators, essentially estimating adversity classes that capture both the number and type of adversities that co-occur. These classes are then used to predict mental health trajectories across the life course. Before assessing latent classes of childhood adversity, Chapter 3 sets the groundwork for the analytic strategy of predicting outcome trajectories by latent classes. To date, there are several methods for including a distal outcome in latent class models, with no clear analytic strategy for when the outcome of interest is a growth model. Therefore, in Chapter 3, I employ a simulation study assessing the performance of five different methods under 27 different data conditions. Results from this study suggest that a maximum-likelihood (ML) approach best captures the true parameter estimates while maintaining substantive clarity. Chapter 4 uses the identified method in Chapter 3 (ML approach) to assess how latent classes of childhood adversity relate to trajectories of mental health using four waves of data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health (Add Health, Wave I-IV). Findings suggest that in addition to a class represented by low adversity experience, there are two classes with greater experiences of adversity. One adversity class, characterized by household dysfunction, has greater depressive symptoms than the low adversity class in early life, and this gap is maintained into mid-adulthood. The other adversity class, characterized by maltreatment, has both greater depressive symptoms than the low adversity class in early life and becomes increasingly more depressed than this group across the life course. Overall, this dissertation contributes both methodologically and substantively to the study of childhood adversity and life course mental health. Childhood adversity has the ability to shape one’s mental health outcomes for many years after childhood, but this relationship is conditional on the lived experiences of adversity. These findings underscore the importance of severity, duration, context, type, and number of adverse events for patterning which children are at greatest risk for mental health problems in adulthood. Future work should consider these elements in favor over an over-simplified measure that may obscure the life course impact of these negative experiences.
Item Open Access Critical Analysis of the Efficacy of Task-Shifting in Two Post-Earthquake Humanitarian Crisis Sites: Haiti and Nepal(2016-05-07) Gault, ElleThis thesis is an in-depth analysis into the efficacy of task-shifting models in post-earthquake settings. Using Haiti and Nepal as case-studies, the paper investigates the necessary infrastructure and policy strategies that must be in place to provide successful post-earthquake mental health interventions.Item Open Access Designing a Voice-Based Treatment Module for Treating Perinatal Depression in Rural Kenya(2014-12-12) Thakore, IshanDepression is the largest contributor to the worldwide disease burden of mental, neurological and substance use disorders. Addressing perinatal depression is a particular challenge in low- and middle-income countries where screening and treatment is not readily available. A potential solution to this treatment gap is shifting treatment from more skilled to less skilled providers. A treatment model using lay counselors in Pakistan demonstrated large reductions in depression rates but is challenging to implement at scale. This study investigated how mobile phones could be used to deliver treatment sessions remotely through an automated voice-based service, thus potentially easing the burden of implementing the program at scale in rural and remote regions. Working in Bungoma County, Kenya, we followed a Human Centered Design approach to adapting and testing a session of an efficacious treatment program developed in Pakistan called the Thinking Healthy Program. We conducted two rounds of testing with community health workers. Participants were randomly assigned to complete the session in person with a single facilitator or as part of a group, or remotely via a mobile phone with or without live operator support. Comprehension of session content was high and not significantly different across in person and phone conditions. Phone implementation was feasible and acceptable to participants, though refinement is needed. Results suggest that automated phone administration could be a viable method to deliver session content. Further testing should assess therapeutic benefits of such as system compared to standard, in person delivery.Item Open Access Developing a Sustainable Model of Text-Delivered Peer Support for Undergraduate Mental Health(2023) Erwin, SavannahThere is increased need for mental health support on college campuses: existing campus resources are increasingly unable to meet the mental health needs of their undergraduate communities. There is also increased preference from students for some forms of emotional support to come from peers. Peer support programs, in which students act as supportive listeners towards their fellow students, are increasingly common on college campuses, but the uptake and utility of these programs is not routinely examined. There is also a need to ensure that the mental health of students providing support is protected. Providing support for peers can be a positive source of meaning and life purpose, but also a source of perceived stress, emotional exhaustion, and, potentially, burnout. If such programs are to be developed and disseminated, it is critical to understand the mechanisms whereby communicating with a peer in a moment of distress can improve mental health outcomes. This dissertation aims to address the critical need of identifying key components for sustainability by providing an updated review of the prevalence and nature of existing undergraduate peer support programs (Study 1), synthesizing research on the impact of providing peer mental health support (Study 2), and evaluating the acceptability and feasibility of a novel text-based peer support program with a sample of undergraduates (Study 3). We found that approximately 10% of institutions affiliated with the American College Health Association have a peer program dedicated to supporting student mental health. Moreover, there has been a recent surge of interest in these programs: over 50% of programs identified were founded in the last 10 years. However, there is limited data collection and even less peer-reviewed research on the impact of these programs for the students receiving and providing support. DukeLine, an innovative text-based peer support program, was designed, implemented, and assessed for sustainability. Peer coaches were trained through a for-credit, semester-long course taught within the Department of Psychology and Neuroscience and committed to providing peer support in two-person shifts for two semesters while enrolled in a practicum course with weekly group supervision. No coach reported experiencing significant emotional exhaustion and, on average, coaches report deriving moderate levels of meaning and purpose from their role as a peer coach. Over a quarter (29.73%) of students who reached out to DukeLine for support did so more than once and 88.89% of texters reported feeling extremely satisfied with the support they received. DukeLine offers a sustainable model for peer support programs targeting undergraduate mental health that is acceptable and feasible, for students who seek and provide support.
Item Open Access Developing and Validating a Perinatal Depression Screening Tool in Bungoma County, Kenya(2016) Tuli, HawaBackground: Depression-screening tools exist and are widely used in Western settings. There have been few studies done to explore whether or not existing tools are valid and effective to use in sub-Saharan Africa. Our study aimed to develop and validate a perinatal depression-screening tool in rural Kenya.
Methods: We utilized conducted free listing and card sorting exercises with a purposive sample of 12 women and 38 CHVs living in a rural community to explore the manifestations of perinatal depression in that setting. We used the information obtained to produce a locally relevant depression-screening tool that comprised of existing Western psychiatric concepts and locally derived items. Subsequently, we administered the novel depression-screening tool and two existing screening tools (the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and the Patient Health Questionnaire-9) to 193 women and compared the results of the screening tool with that of a gold standard structured clinical interview to determine validity.
Results: The free listing and card sorting exercise produced a set of 60 screening items. Of the items in this set, we identified the 10 items that most accurately classified cases and non-cases. This 10-item scale had a sensitivity of 100.0 and specificity of 81.2. This compared to 90.0, 31.5 and 90.0, 49.7 for the EPDS and the PHQ-9, respectively. Overall, we found a prevalence of depression of 5.2 percent.
Conclusions: The new scale does very well in terms of diagnostic validity, having the highest scores in this domain compared to the EPDS, EPDS-R and PHQ-9. The adapted scale does very well with regards to convergent validity-illustrating clear distinction between mean scores across the different categories. It does well with regards to discriminant validity, internal consistency reliability, and test-retest reliability- not securing top scores in those domains but still yielding satisfactory results.
Item Embargo Discrimination in Workplace, Health Care, Family Settings and Mental Health among Transgender People in Sri Lanka(2023) He, TaoDespite numerous studies demonstrating high rates of discrimination and poor mental health among transgender people in Western countries, little research has been conducted on this population in Sri Lanka. As such, the primary objective of this study was to assess the prevalence of discrimination experienced by transgender people in the workplace, health care, and family settings. Additionally, we investigated the potential association between discrimination and adverse mental health outcomes, including current depression, anxiety disorders, and low self-esteem. In Galle, 100 transgender participants were recruited through snowball sampling and then completed the survey through face-to-face interviews. The survey consisted of five sections: sociodemographic information, mental health scales, and discrimination experience in the workplace, health care, and family settings. We reported the prevalence of discrimination and adverse mental health outcomes. We also estimated the prevalence ratios of current depression and anxiety disorder, which are associated with work inaccessibility and workplace discrimination, adjusting for age, education, and gender identity in separate Poisson regression models. The study found that school harassment (67%), workplace insults (63.5%), and work inaccessibility (47.4%) were the most commonly reported types of discrimination among transgender participants. Among them, the prevalence of current depression, anxiety disorder, and low self-esteem were 44%, 38%, and 81%, respectively. Furthermore, work inaccessibility was associated with a 16% increase in the prevalence of depression. Workplace discrimination, as measured by two categories (1 or 2 types of discrimination, ≥3 types of discrimination) was associated with greater prevalence (41%-56%) of depression and anxiety (22% - 46%) than non-discrimination, although all of those associations were not statistically significant. The high prevalence of discrimination against transgender people presented in the study highlights the urgent need for legislative changes to protect their rights. Future studies should aim to identify coping resources and develop evidence-based interventions to minimize the adverse mental health consequences of discrimination. It is expected that the researchers and transgender voluntary groups who had been involved in the study may transform the study results into meaningful real-world interventions.