Browsing by Subject "Wind power"
Results Per Page
Sort Options
Item Open Access A Geospatial Analysis of Wind Energy Development and Authorization Policy on US Forest Service Land(2009-04-24T14:32:26Z) Schlichting, KerryAbstract: Wind is a renewable source of energy but its development has the potential for significant negative visual, economic and environmental impacts if not sited carefully. Analysis of a wide range of variables associated with wind development need to be included in policy development to ensure simultaneous conservation and support of renewable energy development. The objective of this project is to analyze wind energy development to inform US Forest Service management practices through applicable federal, agency, forest and state regulations as well as mitigation of potential impacts. Geospatial analysis is used to evaluate project suitability and associated impacts through a case study of the Nantahala and Pisgah National Forests in North Carolina. This case study is the basis for a spatial decision support system (sDSS) which offers a methodology to consolidate the assessment and authorization process for wind projects on public lands. Based on 16 variables of representing environmental sensitivities, construction requirements, land designations and state policy, this analysis finds that the majority of the study is are highly sensitive or exclusionary to wind energy development. To both promote renewable energy and continued conservation of environmental resources, the Forest Service must take steps to address concerns raised over management practices limiting development potential. Recommendations from this analysis include the need for agency wide clarification of intent and scope of current and proposed Forest Service wind energy management, as well as the prioritization of variable importance in future wind project siting.Item Open Access An interdisciplinary assessment of alternatives for the decarbonization of the electric power sector: Integrating operations research and geospatial analysis to identify cost-efficient strategies for the energy transition(2022) Virguez, EdgarA cost-effective pathway towards net-zero electric power systems requires an extraordinary deployment of new solar and wind generation assets. This aggressive expansion driving unprecedented investment entails a fundamental understanding of the challenge ahead of us. This dissertation seeks to provide a multidisciplinary perspective of research questions that shine the light on rapid and cost-efficient strategies for the energy transition. Integrating operations research and geospatial analysis methods, the dissertation utilizes a multidisciplinary approach when addressing three questions.
First, the dissertation examines the role of battery energy storage technologies (i.e., utility-scale lithium-ion batteries) on reducing the greenhouse gas emissions of an electric power system while simultaneously achieving a reduction in carbon abatement costs. The study uses a cost-based production model (day-ahead unit commitment and a real-time economic dispatch) to simulate the optimal operation of all the generation resources in the largest vertically-integrated electric service region in the U.S. The study explores a multitude of configurations to identify optimal sizing of battery energy storage systems when paired with utility-scale photovoltaics.
Next, the dissertation studies the effect of incorporating high-resolution data when identifying suitable land for renewable energy projects over a geographically defined region. Using a python-based user-friendly siting tool implemented in ArcGIS Pro to perform suitability and cost analysis of utility-scale photovoltaic projects in North Carolina under three scenarios (representing conditions ranging from favorable to restrictive). The study finds that the land suitable for utility-scale photovoltaics reduces substantially when parcel-level data reflecting local land-use restrictions are incorporated. The study's findings highlight the necessity of integrating detailed land-use data that reflects local regulation (zoning ordinances) into siting models while simultaneously increasing their spatial granularity.
Lastly, the dissertation analyzes the benefits of weatherizing wind power farms enabling their operation under extreme climates (winter storms). The study uses global reanalysis data with operational information from the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) during the 2021 winter storm Uri to simulate a continued operation of wind power farms under low-temperature environments. The study finds that the financial benefits that winterized wind turbines would have received during winter storm Uri would have outweighed the capital costs required to implement ice-accretion mitigation actions (before winter storm URI).
Item Open Access ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF FLEXIBLE RAMP CAPABILITY PRODUCTS IN THE MIDCONTINENT ISO(2014-04-25) Cornelius, AdamIn electric power systems, balancing authorities adjust the output of dispatchable coal and natural gas generators in response to changes in net load (electricity demand minus variable generation such as wind). As penetration of renewable energy increases, so do the variability and uncertainty surrounding net load, making balancing more difficult. The flexibility of the system to ramp power output up and down (i.e. ramping capability) may be insufficient to accommodate large changes in net load, potentially leading to scarcity events and threatening system security. The Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO) has proposed ancillary service products called up-ramp capability (URC) and down-ramp capability (DRC) intended to increase system flexibility. The purpose of this study is to explore the economic, environmental, and reliability impacts of MISO’s proposed ramp capability products. Two versions of the unit commitment and economic dispatch processes used by MISO to optimally schedule generators were modeled: (1) a baseline model representing current MISO practices, and (2) a ramp capability model that includes the proposed products. These models were applied to a small power system representative of MISO’s mix of generators under low and high wind penetration levels. In this model the DRC product had no impact, indicating that the representative power system was more flexible in the downward direction than MISO’s actual system, perhaps due to model simplifications or inaccurate assumptions. The URC product, however, did benefit the system. Results show a reduction in the frequency of energy and operating reserve shortages when compared to the baseline model, particularly with high wind penetration, thereby indicating improved reliability. While there was a small price increase in non-shortage intervals due to procurement of URC, this was outweighed by the avoidance of high penalty prices incurred in shortage intervals; the overall average market clearing price was significantly reduced. The URC product also caused a small amount of fuel switching from coal to the more flexible natural gas, slightly reducing the system’s CO2 emissions. However, the more pronounced environmental benefit was the URC product’s ability to help the system absorb increased wind penetration while avoiding most of the corresponding increase in reliability problems.Item Open Access Costs and Emissions Reductions from the Competitive Renewable Energy Zones (CREZ) Wind Transmission Project in Texas(2011-04-29) Kwok, Gabriel; Greathouse, TylerWind power has the potential to significantly reduce air emissions from the electric power sector, but the best wind sites are located far from load centers and will require new transmission lines. Texas currently has the largest installed wind power capacity in the U.S., but a lack of transmission capacity between the western part of the state, where most wind farms are located, and the major load centers in the east has led to frequent wind curtailments. State policymakers have addressed this issue by approving a $5 billion transmission project, the Competitive Renewable Energy Zones (CREZ), which will expand the transmission capacity to 18,456 MW by 2014. In this paper, we examine the impacts of large-scale wind power in ERCOT, the power market that serves 85% of the state’s load, after the completion of the CREZ project. We assess the generation displaced and the resulting emissions reductions. We then examine the public costs of wind to estimate the CO2 abatement cost. We develop an economic dispatch model of ERCOT to quantify the generation displaced by wind power and the emissions reductions in 2014. Since there is uncertainty about the amount of new wind developed between now and 2014, three wind penetration scenarios were assessed that correspond to wind supplying 9%, 14% and 21% of ERCOT’s total generation. In the 21% wind energy penetration scenario, the CREZ transmission capacity is fully utilized, and wind displaces natural gas 74% of the time and coal 26% of the time. This results in CO2, NOX, SO2 and Hg emissions reductions of 19%, 17%, 13%, and 15%, and a CO2 abatement cost of $60 per ton of CO2. Lower wind penetrations result in gas being displaced more frequently, lower emissions reductions and an abatement cost up to $91 per ton of CO2. Our results should be compared with other technologies and policies so that policymakers can cost-effectively reduce emissions.Item Open Access Economic Analysis of Dispatchable CCS Integrated with Wind Power(2011-04-28) Zhang, SiyingPost-combustion Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS) promises to substantially reduce CO2 emissions from conventional coal-fired power plants. The key barrier to commercialization is its high operational cost due to a significant energy penalty. Dispatchable CCS has the potential to reduce the revenue loss by taking advantage of the volatility of energy prices. In addition, dispatchable CCS can serve as a cost effective way to integrate intermittent electricity generation from renewable sources. This project investigates the economic feasibility of retrofitting Powerton Power Plant in Illinois with dispatchable CCS (both in two-mode and three-mode arrangements) and integrating it with one local wind farm. A simulation model is used to estimate the incremental costs and incremental revenues associated with a dispatchable CCS system and wind integration in comparison to conventional continuously-operated CCS system. According to the simulation results, flexible operation of CCS integrated with wind power effectively mitigates the profit loss due to the CCS energy penalty. A two-mode arrangement dispatchable CCS integrated with this wind farm generates approximately 2.5 billion dollars in a period 30 years while the total profit from a three-mode arrangement system varies from 1 to 2.4 billion dollars. Comparing incremental costs and revenues, it can be concluded that the two-mode arrangement is more suitable for Powerton power plant because it generates positive profit even without the wind farm. More research needs to be conducted before we extend this conclusion to other utilities, however, flexible operation of CCS and synergy with wind power promise to lower the carbon price needed to make CCS economic.Item Open Access The Potential of Energy Storage Systems with Respect to Generation Adequacy and Economic Viability(2013) Bradbury, Kyle JosephIntermittent energy resources, including wind and solar power, continue to be rapidly added to the generation fleet domestically and abroad. The variable power of these resources introduces new levels of stochasticity into electric interconnections that must be continuously balanced in order to maintain system reliability. Energy storage systems (ESSs) offer one potential option to compensate for the intermittency of renewables. ESSs for long-term storage (1-hour or greater), aside from a few pumped hydroelectric installations, are not presently in widespread use in the U.S. The deployment of ESSs would be most likely driven by either the potential for a strong internal rate of return (IRR) on investment and through significant benefits to system reliability that independent system operators (ISOs) could incentivize.
To assess the potential of ESSs three objectives are addressed. (1) Evaluate the economic viability of energy storage for price arbitrage in real-time energy markets and determine system cost improvements for ESSs to become attractive investments. (2) Estimate the reliability impact of energy storage systems on the large-scale integration of intermittent generation. (3) Analyze the economic, environmental, and reliability tradeoffs associated with using energy storage in conjunction with stochastic generation.
First, using real-time energy market price data from seven markets across the U.S. and the physical parameters of fourteen ESS technologies, the maximum potential IRR of each technology from price arbitrage was evaluated in each market, along with the optimal ESS system size. Additionally, the reductions in capital cost needed to achieve a 10% IRR were estimated for each ESS. The results indicate that the profit-maximizing size of an ESS is primarily determined by its technological characteristics (round-trip charge/discharge efficiency and self-discharge) and not market price volatility, which instead increases IRR. This analysis demonstrates that few ESS technologies are likely to be implemented by investors alone.
Next, the effects of ESSs on system reliability are quantified. Using historic data for wind, solar, and conventional generation, a correlation-preserving, copula-transform model was implemented in conjunction with Markov chain Monte Carlo framework for estimating system reliability indices. Systems with significant wind and solar penetration (25% or greater), even with added energy storage capacity, resulted in considerable decreases in generation adequacy.
Lastly, rather than analyzing the reliability and costs in isolation of one another, system reliability, cost, and emissions were analyzed in 3-space to quantify and visualize the system tradeoffs. The modeling results implied that ESSs perform similarly to natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) systems with respect to generation adequacy and system cost, with the primary difference being that the generation adequacy improvements are less for ESSs than that of NGCC systems and the increase in LCOE is greater for ESSs than NGCC systems.
Although ESSs do not appear to offer greater benefits than NGCC systems for managing energy on time intervals of 1-hour or more, we conclude that future research into short-term power balancing applications of ESSs, in particular for frequency regulation, is necessary to understand the full potential of ESSs in modern electric interconnections.