City of Cincinnati Streetcar Project: Financial Outlook and Funding Recommendations
Abstract
In 2016, the City of Cincinnati will begin operating its 3.6-mile urban circulator
streetcar system. This report analyzes the financial impact to the city and is based
on the attached Flow of Funds Statement. Though the city is receiving $45 million
in federal grants to fund the project, the capital costs burden falls largely on the
city. After including private contributions and other external inflows, the city is
responsible for $82 million of the capital costs, and has set aside an additional
$15 million should it have to pay for utilities relocation.
Projected revenues from the system include: fare revenue, pavement maintenance savings,
liquidation of the system, and incremental property tax revenue. Baseline fare revenue
projections, assuming a $1.00 fare and initial daily demand of 3,700 riders, predict
that the system will recover 42% of operational and maintenance (O&M) costs in the
first full year of operation. However, as O&M costs rise at a higher rate than ridership,
this ratio is expected to decline to 27% by 2035. This translates to a $1.8 million
deficit and $5.4 million deficit in 2017 and 2035, respectively. The financial viability
of the system depends on the city’s ability to decrease the rate of O&M cost growth
and/or increase ridership. Fare revenue should only be expected to account for a portion
of O&M costs. Sensitivity analysis was conducted to show the effects of a range of
variables on fare revenue and incremental property tax revenue. These ranges provide
a range of estimates of the operating shortfall and should be used to guide decisions
on how to fund the shortfall.
It is highly unlikely that the system will be self-sustaining. A combination of advertising
revenue, tax increment financing, private contributions, along-the-line assessments,
and special improvement district revenue should be used to account for the remaining
costs. Use of city general fund revenue should be avoided at all costs, so as to not
disrupt current city service delivery.
Type
Master's projectDepartment
The Sanford School of Public PolicyPermalink
https://hdl.handle.net/10161/8472Citation
Trame, P. Blair (2014). City of Cincinnati Streetcar Project: Financial Outlook and Funding Recommendations.
Master's project, Duke University. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/10161/8472.More Info
Show full item record
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.
Rights for Collection: Sanford School Master of Public Policy (MPP) Program Master’s Projects
Works are deposited here by their authors, and represent their research and opinions, not that of Duke University. Some materials and descriptions may include offensive content. More info