Religious Conviction, Respect, and the Doctrine of Restraint in the Exclusionist-Inclusionist Debate

dc.contributor.advisor

Golding, Martin P

dc.contributor.author

McWatters III, Thomas A.

dc.date.accessioned

2010-05-10T20:19:40Z

dc.date.available

2010-05-10T20:19:40Z

dc.date.issued

2010

dc.department

Philosophy

dc.description.abstract

The principle of respect for other persons is commonly invoked in contemporary liberalism as justification for the claim that a conscientious citizen in a liberal democracy is morally obligated to refrain from supporting a coercive law for which he lacks suitable public justification. This view has been challenged by Christopher Eberle in Religious Conviction in Liberal Politics, who argues that although a citizen has an obligation to pursue a convincing secular rationale for a coercive law, he does not have an obligation to withhold support for a law for which he lacks such a rationale.

In this dissertation I attempt to develop a basic analytical framework which can be used to formulate a suitable conception of respect for persons in the public square. Only with such an underlying conception of respect in hand is it possible to adjudicate the competing claims concerning what the principle of respect for persons should be deemed to require of citizens in advocating and supporting coercive laws.

The framework I propose views respect for persons as a complex and variegated concept. It separately considers four different forms or notions of respect, and takes the attitude of respect as foundational and prior to the other forms of respect. I conclude that any conception of respect will entail commitment to a broader ethical theory or set of ethical principles. Accordingly, in the final chapter, I suggest that Robert Audi's "value-based Kantian intuitionism," with its emphasis on respect and the dignity of persons as a grounding property, may constitute an auspicious ethical theory to which appeal may plausibly be made in completing a conception of respect.

dc.identifier.uri

https://hdl.handle.net/10161/2485

dc.language.iso

en_US

dc.subject

Philosophy

dc.subject

Contemporary liberalism

dc.subject

Doctrine of restraint

dc.subject

Public square

dc.subject

Religious conviction

dc.subject

Respect

dc.title

Religious Conviction, Respect, and the Doctrine of Restraint in the Exclusionist-Inclusionist Debate

dc.type

Dissertation

Files

Original bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name:
D_McWatters III_Thomas_a_201005.pdf
Size:
911.01 KB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format

Collections