Photography Otherwise: Denaturing Colonial Visualities in Contemporary Native American Art

The visual representation of Indigenous North American peoples in contemporary visual culture continues to rely on romanticized images drawn from early twentieth century salvage ethnography surveys, presenting Indigenous American nations as part of the continent’s storied past while denying their active presence in contemporary society. This dissertation explores a body of conceptual art photography, created between the 1990’s and the present, that responds uniquely to the persistence of romantic ethnographic visual tropes. Focusing on the work of artists who are members of Native American nations situated within the United States, this study explores the relationships among anthropological visual conventions, Western philosophies defining what it means to be human, Western academic theories of photography, and settler-colonial history in North America. It delves specifically into the links between the foundations of anthropological visualities and later twentieth century theory positing the photographic image as a mode of death, popularized by scholars including Roland Barthes, Susan Sontag, and Martha Rosler, among others. I consider how the contemporary artists addressed intervene in these theoretical discourses of photography by way of interjecting elements of performance into photography. I identify and analyze strategies including the appropriation and physical manipulation of historic images; a reimaging of the photographic act; performative interventions into the still image; the use of satire and affect; Indigenous Futurisms; storytelling; and a radical collapsing of the boundaries between performance action and photography.