Show simple item record

Reading and Writing As/if: US Literary Criticism and Identity

dc.contributor.advisor Wiegman, Robyn Gregory, Chase Paulina 2019-06-07T19:49:44Z 2019
dc.description Dissertation
dc.description.abstract <p>As/if: US Literary Criticism and Identity turns to early queer and third-wave feminist scholarship to identify a unique strategy and style of literary criticism, which I name as/if criticism. As/if criticism is both born of and resistant to two conflicting imperatives in the US academy, which first come to a fore during the 1990s. The first is the demand to write “as”: that is, the institutional demand that critics use their gender, race, sexuality, etc. as credentials of authentic knowledge. The second is the demand to write “as if”: that is, the post-structuralist demand that critique suspend the idea of knowable or stable identity. Challenging both of these demands, as/if criticism employs four different strategies—recognition, qualification, intimacy, and interruption—in order to disrupt identity as it is produced and valued as a knowable category within literary criticism. Taking five authors as case studies, I examine Eve Sedgwick’s compendium of queer critical essays, Tendencies (1993); Deborah McDowell’s debut work of black feminist criticism, The Changing Same (1995); Barbara Johnson’s deconstructive take on race and gender, The Feminist Difference (1995); and Robert Reid-Pharr’s innovative critical essay collection, Black Gay Man (2001). Over the course of its chapters, As/if: US Literary Criticism and Identity makes the case that as/if criticism is well-suited to describe fraught social bonds, experimental allegiances, and unintuitive cross-identifications because its style mirrors the substance of its argument.</p>
dc.subject Literature
dc.subject Gender studies
dc.subject Sexuality
dc.subject as/if
dc.subject black feminist theory
dc.subject literary criticism
dc.subject queer theory
dc.title Reading and Writing As/if: US Literary Criticism and Identity
dc.type Dissertation
dc.department Literature
duke.embargo.months 23
duke.embargo.release 2021-05-21T00:00:00Z

Files in this item


This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record