Bias on the Bench: How Judges’ Legal Backgrounds Influence Their Decisions

dc.contributor.advisor

Vanberg, Georg

dc.contributor.author

Shortley, Kristen

dc.date.accessioned

2016-06-11T18:23:21Z

dc.date.available

2016-06-11T18:23:21Z

dc.date.issued

2016-06-11

dc.department

Political Science

dc.description.abstract

The ideal conception of a judge is that of a neutral arbitrator. However, there exist good reasons to believe that personal characteristics, including professional experiences, bias judges. Such suspicions inspired two hypotheses: (1) judges that are former prosecutors are biased in favor of the government in criminal appeals; (2) judges that are former criminal defense attorneys are biased in favor of the criminal appellant. These hypotheses were tested by gathering professional information about state supreme court judges in the south during the years from 1995 until 1998. That was then matched to an existing database that recorded those judges’ demographics and decisions in criminal appeals during that time. Logistic regressions of that data revealed that despite when other characteristics, including gender, race, and legal experience, were accounted for, criminal defense remained a statistically significant predictor. Judges with a background in criminal defense were more likely to reverse criminal court decisions. In contrast, prosecutorial experience was not a good predictor of how a judge ruled. Judges that had backgrounds in prosecution did not rule much differently than those that did not have such a background.

dc.identifier.uri

https://hdl.handle.net/10161/12392

dc.language.iso

en_US

dc.subject

judicial bias, implicit bias, judicial behavior, judicial background, criminal appeals, state supreme courts

dc.title

Bias on the Bench: How Judges’ Legal Backgrounds Influence Their Decisions

dc.type

Honors thesis

Files

Original bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name:
!!! Shortley Thesis Bias on the Bench 20160326.pdf
Size:
532 KB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format