Fragile Masculinity: Operationalizing and Testing a Novel Model of Identity Fragility

dc.contributor.advisor

Gaither, Sarah

dc.contributor.advisor

Gassman-Pines, Anna

dc.contributor.author

Stanaland, Adam

dc.date.accessioned

2022-09-21T13:54:35Z

dc.date.available

2023-09-16T08:17:13Z

dc.date.issued

2022

dc.department

Psychology and Neuroscience

dc.description.abstract

In this dissertation, I propose, operationalize, and test a novel model of identity fragility using fragile masculinity as a case study. To date, identity research has largely focused on understanding how people’s membership in different social categories (e.g., gender, race) shapes their experiences, self-concept, and behavior. I contend that when (i) a social category is high-status and (ii) its corresponding norms are especially rigid—as is often the case with masculinity—people in this category may feel pressured to uphold its norms in order to maintain their status. To the extent that identities are pressured, I argue that they are “fragile”, in turn eliciting compensatory, stereotypical responses (e.g., male aggression) to perceived threats aimed at maintaining status. Supporting the proposed model, I found that young men’s (Study 1) and post-pubertal boys’ (Study 3) aggressive cognition post-threat was directly related to the extent to which their masculine behavior was extrinsically motivated (pressured). In Study 2, I found that straight men’s anti-gay bias was again predicted by a combination of extrinsic pressure and threat, which was partially mediated by men’s endorsement of gender-inversion stereotypes (e.g., gay = feminine). Finally, as one possible pathway to reduce these adverse pressures and compensatory aggression, in Study 4, I found that identity-salient events like U.S. presidential elections can loosen masculinity norms from the “top-down” to mitigate certain men’s sociopolitical aggression.

dc.identifier.uri

https://hdl.handle.net/10161/25764

dc.subject

Social psychology

dc.subject

Developmental psychology

dc.subject

Public policy

dc.subject

Manhood

dc.subject

Masculinity

dc.subject

Motivation

dc.subject

Social identity

dc.subject

Threat

dc.title

Fragile Masculinity: Operationalizing and Testing a Novel Model of Identity Fragility

dc.type

Dissertation

duke.embargo.months

11.835616438356164

Files

Original bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name:
Stanaland_duke_0066D_16882.pdf
Size:
1.91 MB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format

Collections