Understanding the Hypercorrection Effect: Why High-Confidence Errors are More Likely to be Corrected

dc.contributor.advisor

Marsh, Elizabeth

dc.contributor.author

Fazio, Lisa K.

dc.date.accessioned

2010-05-10T19:57:05Z

dc.date.available

2012-05-01T04:30:05Z

dc.date.issued

2010

dc.department

Psychology and Neuroscience

dc.description.abstract

The hypercorrection effect refers to the finding that high-confidence errors are more likely to be corrected after feedback than are low-confidence errors (Butterfield & Metcalfe, 2001). In 5 experiments I examine the hypercorrection effect, offer possible explanations for why the effect occurs, and examine the durability of the effect. In Experiment 1, I replicate the hypercorrection effect and show that delaying the feedback does not reduce the effect. In a secondary item analysis I also show that the effect is not caused by "tricky" questions. In Experiments 2 and 3, I show that subjects are more likely to remember the source of the feedback after both high-confidence errors and low-confidence correct responses. This suggests that it is the discrepancy between the subject's expectation and the actual feedback that causes the hypercorrection effect. In Experiment 4 I show that the hypercorrection effect also occurs for episodic false memories showing the diversity of the effect. Finally, in Experiment 5 I examine the durability of the effect. Initial high-confidence errors that are corrected after feedback remain corrected one week later.

dc.format.extent

983978 bytes

dc.format.mimetype

application/pdf

dc.identifier.uri

https://hdl.handle.net/10161/2388

dc.language.iso

en_US

dc.subject

Psychology, Cognitive

dc.subject

confidence

dc.subject

feedback

dc.subject

memory

dc.subject

metacognition

dc.title

Understanding the Hypercorrection Effect: Why High-Confidence Errors are More Likely to be Corrected

dc.type

Dissertation

duke.embargo.months

24

Files

Original bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name:
D_Fazio_Lisa_a_201005.pdf
Size:
960.92 KB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format

Collections